Showing posts with label Commercials. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commercials. Show all posts

Saturday, November 03, 2007

So who is on your side?

Here in Hampton Roads, there are three major news stations: Channel 13 News, (WVEC) Channel 10 News, (WAVY) and Channel 3 News. (WTKR) Currently WVEC is at the top of the ratings, with WAVY behind as a tough competitor. WTKR is, regrettably for them, dead last with no hope of gaining the top any time soon. Long ago they were at the top of their game, but now they have sunk very very low.

Usually in competition you can expect some dirty games, but as of late it's reached a whole new level. WTKR recently launched attack ads against WAVY. The first thing that should make a person laugh is the fact they're attacking the #2 competitor, not #1. The second thing should be the ads themselves.

The ads consist of a caricature of WAVY's Andy Fox lampooning the station's motto, namely "We're on your side." The most simplest ad is this one:

Ad #1

Then there's this one:

Ad #2

And finally this one, which tops them all:

Ad #3

When I first saw these, I think my reaction was the same as everyone else who watched it:

"What the heck was that?!"

Channel 3 apparently seriously thinks this will make a difference. The general reaction to these has been a negative one, in fact I dare say WTKR has hurt themselves more than WAVY or WVEC could ever hope to try.

I have to say is this doesn't make any sense. In accusing it of not being on any one's side, it's almost as if they're saying a media outlet should be biased, or leaning towards a specific opinion. No one wants this - every one desires a news station to have unbiased reporting (if that's even possible in and of itself). The example with the sports team only works with sports, not with news broadcasting. I also have to say is that one commercial with the "convicted felon" is pretty gutsy. I mean, can you imagine a political ad where they had an actor playing Hillary Clinton standing next to Osama bin Laden and saying, "I'm on his side!"

All in all, these ads are just what I've made them: a joke. A desperate attempt to attack the #2 in the region with a joke that was weak to begin with and made even weaker when put into a tangible metaphor. I don't have much else to say about this. These really speak for themselves.