Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts

Friday, January 05, 2007

Can you google "hypocrisy?"

This was inspired to by a double-standard I noticed with Google and Yahoo. (but in particular Google) There were two incidents: the first took place in America, the second in China. While the America incident was a single case, the China situation is still continuing as far as I know.

About a year back, the Department of Justice went to Google asking for information. According to the BBC article, they asked for:
  • A list of terms entered into the search engine during an unspecified single week, potentially tens of millions of queries
  • A million randomly selected web addresses from various Google databases.
The reason for the request was to combat child pornography. (and apparently fight possible terrorism) Google responded that they would not comply, saying that it might reveal trade secrets and would hurt her trust with users. They also argued that many other search engines - including Yahoo and AOL - had already complied with the government on similar requests. The Justice Department responded that other search engines yielded poor results, and that Google would probably have the best program to find such data regarding child pornography and just how easy it is to find the rubbish. Anyone who has ever tried to use Yahoo or AOL can probably sympathize with that.

Yet, as the previously linked BBC article points out, there are already internet laws in action to safeguard data while allowing justice officials investigating crimes to search for what they need. The problem with this case was there was no crime being investigated, and some feared the Justice Department might set a precedent of being able to access anything any time they wanted.

Granted, whatever you think of this individual case is irrelevant to my point. The same month as this incident, Google opened in China. What does Google.cn do? It "blocks politically sensitive material to comply with Chinese censorship rule." One Reuters reporter in Beijing described how she couldn't find anything about the New York Times, The Washington Times, BBC News or any websites about Tiananmen square. Even more amusing, looking for banned or rebellious groups will redirect you to "condemnatory articles." Along with Yahoo, Google handed over personal data to the Chinese government. There was an incident in 2003 in which "Chinese police who had been monitoring message boards, blogs and personal emails, asked for the sign up account details of two anonymous bloggers. These were handed over by Yahoo China to the Chinese Government."

Google's argument for their actions is that it would "
be more damaging to pull out of China altogether and says that in contrast to other search engines, it will inform users when access is restricted on certain search terms." Yahoo claims they do not have a say in the affairs of their Chinese branch, but many journalists point out that employees from the various companies are personally customizing the list of banned words even without Chinese interference. Chinese journalists involved with the national media admit there are "30,000 people involved in maintaining censorship within the Chinese government, monitoring information and discussions on message boards." They say, however, that while "each case is very sad for the people involved, fifty seven people arrested in a country of 1.4 billion is not very much." I would think even one person arrested for speaking out or thinking contrary to the government would be a tragedy.

So even if you say, "Google was right to defy the Justice Department," you have to admit there is some hypocrisy here. This is especially so as Google and Yahoo pride themselves in being able to let people access any information any time they need to. I'd like to say, "It's those evil corporations again!" but uh...well, that's borderline to going on about "the Man."

Wednesday, October 25, 2006

Be thankful - no I'm serious

I don't want to sound cliche, but...Americans really are spoiled. We have so much to be thankful for, yet we find so much to complain about. And no, I'm not trying to claim infallibility - I too am guilty of doing this.

A few months ago I was doing research on Zimbabwe and how much Robert Mugabe has sent that nation into economic turmoil. It's humbling to read about starvation, poverty, and lack of energy, and then head out and everywhere in America you see food, working electricity, and plenty of gasoline. (even if people complain about prices, at least it's still there when you wake up) We're also thankful to have competent leadership. I don't care what any Democrat says - I would rather have a congress full of George W. Bush clones than have Robert Mugabe as my president.

You look at tyrannical governments like the one in Belarus and you're thankful for the little things we take for granted. Coming up are the November elections, something everyone will be able to participate in freely, and if you don't like the results you're allowed to protest. Byelorussians, meanwhile, are locked away for disliking the government, and if you protest you can disappear without a trace. Heck, even semi-democracies like Russia have problems, where more reporters have been killed than any other nation. Charles Gibson is lucky that he can go to home without a government/mafia hired killer shooting him in the head for what he said about the war in Iraq. (by the way, I have nothing against Charles Gibson, I just used him as an example)

Generally, we can all live in peace, with our only fear being crime. When my dad told me about the mass graves he found while serving in Bosnia, I was thankful that I could walk down the street and not be shot at because of my religion or ethnicity. When you hear about the condition in Darfur, spiraling out of control as we speak, you have to be thankful that no ethnic group in America is trying to drive out the other by force. Maybe people don't like that illegal Americans are being arrested and shipped back home, but at least the American military isn't bombing migrant camps.

Recently I've been following the conflict going on in Palestine right now. Armed groups loyal to either Fatah or Hamas have been combating one another for some time now. Their battles are sporadic and could hardly be called huge clashes, but nonetheless they cause more tension. Foreign Arab nations - including Egypt and Qatar - have attempted to get both sides to come to an agreement, but neither side has given ground. Hamas still refuses to acknowledge Israel's right to exist and refuses to recognize any previous agreements signed with Israel, (including those that allow Palestine to exist) while Fatah wants to go ahead with plans to cooperate with Israel and is growing tired of Hamas trying to undermine their authority, especially in the Gaza Strip. Many analysts are already saying a civil war between the two sides is imminent.

As I read these stories about the crisis in Palestine, I can't help but think about our own nation. What if the the Republicans and Democrats took up arms? What if they started to fight a war of weapons rather than with words? That is another thing we can be thankful for - the fact our political system is one of the most stable in the world. I may complain about the attack ads on TV right now, especially those between Senator George Allen and opponent Jim Webb, but at least the Allen and Webb supporters aren't firing rockets at each other. I don't hear any stories about Jim Webb's campaign manager being killed by Allen's militia men. (and no, I don't have anything against Jim Webb's campaign manager either) This is probably why it is a good thing political parties are not armed, because these things would invariably happen. Our military is thankfully nonpartisan, and will function no matter who is put in charge come this election. When Hamas took control of the Palestinian parliament, the Fatah controlled armed forces scoffed at any attempt for Hamas to give them orders. Imagine if a Democrat took control of the presidency and the military refused to cooperate.

America has some problems that we need to deal with, but everyday I have a lot to be thankful for. I just wish a lot of fellow Americans would realize this as well. If you feel bad about your nation, and you want something to make you realize how lucky you are, just start reading international news. Trust me, it'll cheer you up in a jiffy.

Monday, October 09, 2006

"Gnome" Chomsky



Wow, I put off this blog too long. I need to get in shape and start posting more. Any way, that's one reason I've posted three pictures rather than my traditional one piece. I figure I have to make up for some lost time, and make sure this entry packs a punch. My target is the "scholar" Noam Chomsky, (and yes, his first name is pronounced like "gnome") who is currently a linguistics professor at MIT and has written numerous books and articles related to America internal and foreign policy. He is also a heavy critic of Israel and the American government.

Some call him one of the greatest minds of our time, but in all honesty I cannot understand why people take him seriously. Actually that's not true - I can understand why he has an audience, but I'll get to that later. Some of you might be wondering, "Who is Noam Chomsky, aside from what you said in the first paragraph? Why do you dislike him?" Noam Chomsky is the quintessential left-wing professor you always hear right-wing people talk about. To simplify things, he's the typical "America does nothing right" voice that the extreme left panders to. It's fair to say he blows everything done by America into a negative light, whether it was for good or bad. In this article from his website, first printed on September 12, 2001 he opens with:
The September 11 attacks were major atrocities. In terms of number of victims they do not reach the level of many others, for example, Clinton's bombing of the Sudan with no credible pretext, destroying half its pharmaceutical supplies and probably killing tens of thousands of people (no one knows, because the US blocked an inquiry at the UN and no one cares to pursue it).
No one knows, yet he jumps to conclusions and states numbers any way? And destroying half of its pharmaceutical supplies? And no pretext? I'm sorry, what were those terrorist attacks on our embassies again? And if I recall correctly, that "medicine factory" had in fact been used by terrorists before. One wonders, with the atrocities in Darfur right now, Clinton shouldn't have become more involved in Sudan than simply bombing suspected Al Qaeda hide-outs. I also find it funny people are looking back on those attacks as justified now, because it was a chance to defeat Al Qaeda pre-September 11, yet Chomsky sees otherwise because he personally didn't find attacks against American soil "credible pretext."

I might also add that after September 11 Chomsky and many others claimed the press was too nice to Bush, and this led to the idea of a conservative bias in the media. I think this is a laughable belief now, with the press reporting everything bad happening with the Bush administration. (some criticism deserved, some not) I might also add Chomsky is constantly a hypocrite, portraying America (and Israel) as this great devil yet not looking down upon other states. He is constantly sympathetic to terrorist or tyrannical regimes. My cartoon with him saying Chavez's views are constructive is, sadly, directly quoting Chomsky when he heard Chavez had promoted his book. I find it ironic Chomsky calls America a "failed state" because of things like the Patriot Act (which, by the way, still limits government actions by the court) yet promotes places like Venezuela where Chavez actually has laws that limit what the press can say about the government. Sadly, Chomsky discussed another tyrannical power in his article regarding Iran's nuclear crisis, and discussing his three-step solution:
The first is to call off the very credible US and Israeli threats that virtually urge Iran to develop nuclear weapons as a deterrent. A second step would be to join the rest of the world in accepting a verifiable Fissban treaty, as well as ElBaradei’s proposal, or something similar. A third step would be to live up to article six of the NPT, which obligates the nuclear states to take "good-faith" efforts to eliminate nuclear weapons, a binding legal obligation, as the world court determined.
This is an absurd statement. The "very credible" threats from the US and Israel towards Iran developing nuclear weapons is because Iran supports terrorism abroad and has made statements like "Israel should be wiped off the face of the map." (then again, I think Chomsky would like that) The last two suggestions are assuming Iran can be trusted to live up to their end of the bargain, which precedent has shown they cannot. Yet Chomsky assures us (and keep in mind this article was written June 23, 2006) that Iran can be trusted, and they only feel threatened. One wonders why Chomsky can't see that Iran could follow the route of Libya: Libya was disliked by the international community, but gave up nuclear ambitions and allowed foreign powers to review her country, and has over the past ten years rebuilt the foreign relations she lost during the 1980's. You do not see Libya hoping to defend herself with nukes, why should Iran and North Korea?

The thing that drives me crazy the most is his constant belittling of Israel. At the risk of sounding judgmental, his articles almost read like something you would read on a PLO propaganda site. An example is seen in his article regarding Israel's recent war with Lebanon:
The Gaza “disengagement” was openly announced as a West Bank expansion plan. Having turned Gaza into a disaster area, sane Israeli hawks realized that there was no point leaving a few thousand settlers taking the best land and scarce resources, protected by a large part of the IDF. It made more sense to send them to the West Bank and Golan Heights, where new settlement programs were announced, while turning Gaza into “the world’s largest prison,” as Israeli human rights groups accurately call it. West Bank “Convergence” formalizes these programs of annexation, cantonization, and imprisonment. With decisive US support, Israel is annexing valuable lands and the most important resources of the West Bank (primarily water), while carrying out settlement and infrastructure projects that divide the shrinking Palestinian territories into unviable cantons, virtually separated from one another and from whatever pitiful corner of Jerusalem will be left to Palestinians. All are to be imprisoned as Israel takes over the Jordan Valley, and of course any other access to the outside world.
This is conspiracy theory rubbish at its worse. Sometimes I read his articles and I wonder to myself, "Does he actually believe what he writes?" He spins Israel's pull-out from Gaza (part of the Roadmap for Peace that many Israelis were against and was expected to be a disaster) and turns it into this grand conspiracy where Israel plans to annex all of Palestine and "imprison" all the Palestinians as they "take over" the Jordan Valley. Funny, when Israel controlled the Jordan Valley after 1967 there were no massive concentration camps, I wonder why the Israelis would start now? He also fails to mention a couple of things: 1) the Gaza Strip became a mess because of the Palestinian powers within, such as the terrorist organizations that are still there today causing a mess, and 2) the reason the settlers are protected by the IDF is because Palestinian terrorists are sneaking into the settlements and killing men, women, and children at indiscretion. By the way, remember my blog entry here? Yes, my entry where I showed that progressive Hamas officials were saying, "Wait a minute - we ruined Gaza, and we are at blame here for Israel's aggression." When members of a terrorist organization say they ruined a country and a foreign "scholar" argues still that it is the Jewish state that did it, it gets absurd.

Chomsky is, ironically, Jewish, so claiming anti-Semitism would seem a paradox. He does, however, have a bizarre history involving Holocaust denial and criticism of Israel. A French lecturer named Robert Faurisson wrote a book and gave talks describing the Holocaust as a hoax, and going on to say the gas chambers never existed and the Jews were responsible for World War II - in fact, the Holocaust was concocted by American Zionists. When Faurisson was suspended by the University of Lyon, Chomsky defended him and said that his findings were based on "extensive historical research." After writing an actual foreword for Faurisson's next book - another Holocaust denial - Chomsky said:
I see no anti-Semitic implications in denial of the existence of gas chambers, or even denial of the Holocaust. Nor would there be anti-Semitic implications, per se in the claim that the Holocaust (whether one believes it took place or not) is being exploited, viciously so, by apologists for Israeli repression and violence. I see no hint of anti-Semitic implications in Faurisson's work.
When Alan Dershowitz - a liberal Jew, like Chomsky - criticized Chomsky's support for Faurisson, Chomsky responded that Faurisson was not anti-Semitic but anti-Zionist because he denounced "Zionist lies." When Dershowitz called for an open debate on the matter Chomsky responded that "it is obvious there is no point in debating it because nobody believes there is an anti-Semitic connotation to the denial of the Holocaust." Paul L. Berman, writing in the Village Voice, wrote that "Chomsky's view of anti-Semitism is positively wild. His definition is so narrow, neither the Protocols of the Elders of Zion nor the no-Holocaust delusion fit into it...his present remarks on anti-Semitism and Zionist lies disqualify him from ever being taken seriously on matters pertaining to Jews." This is an excellent point, considering that Chomsky is a linguistics professor, yet he is constantly sought after for advice on government and foreign affairs. Alan Dershowitz made an even finer point by saying in his book "The Case for Israel" that "there is a difference between mere criticism of Israel and singling it out for unique sanctions such as divestiture or boycott." (pg 216) So while I cannot label Chomsky an anti-Semite, I do believe this shows he is truly delusional about political matters and what is right or wrong.

In truth, Noam Chomsky becomes tiring to read after a while because his pattern is too repetitive. Everything America does is bad. Everything Israel does is bad. Everyone else is a saint and does nothing wrong, and everyone from Iran to Luxemburg is a victim of American aggression. I realized some time after reading more in-depth on his attitude that he is really no different than any angry teenager on the internet who thinks he has the low-down on political affairs. The only difference is while the angry teenager uses leet speak and shortened phrases like "omg" and "lol," Noam Chomsky speaks in full sentences. Maybe it is obvious why he has such a huge following. He appeals to those angry people out there that think with their wild emotions rather than with their logic. It is therefore truly sad that he has such a huge following of supporters, because it means people take him seriously.

I wonder if a young man with a major in Animation can be just as well respected in foreign policy? I should write a few books...yeah that's the ticket...then again, is there a market for guys that think America is only partly to blame for the world's troubles? Probably not...

Sunday, April 16, 2006

On censorship and "hyphenated Americans"

Here's an interesting image. What you are seeing are two versions of a comic I did for The District. The comic was done in response to a kid's bike getting stolen by a homeless guy who had somehow gotten past security. My goal was ultimately just to mock the incompetant security guards who seem to man our walls, as well as pick on any organization - school or company - who chooses guards based on need rather than merit. The comics editor said he was worried about people being offended by my portrayal of the African-American guard, so I erased the lines and put on some glasses and reworded what he was saying. Instantly, it was much "better."

I'm not going to go on a rant about The District. I hate it when artists attack their employers over trivial matters, and besides I appreciate them for letting me work at all. (not to mention for being very lenient in regards to deadlines and fixing my mistakes) What just amuses me is how wrong my point was taken. I wasn't trying to plaster a caricature in the paper and say, "Behold! This is how what all black people are like!" I made him talk like that because - guess what? - that's how our guards talked. I've always believed the worse stereotype is from people who stereotype themselves. If black Americans don't want to be portrayed in a "Yo yo fo' Biggie" kind of atmosphere, then don't act like that in such a way that makes people laugh. It's not that slang is bad or that it's not good to speak the way you want to, but there's a reason white people aren't walking around talking like some yuppie at a golf club. To put it another way, I read a review of "Half Past Dead" that compared Jah Rule to other rappers: you see, there are some rappers like Fifty Cent who have grown up in the ghetto and know what life on the street is, and then there are rappers like Jah Rule who like to pretend they do so they can fit into the whole rap schibang. Let me put it in another perspective: being white and acting "black" to be cool (like posers do - geez do I hate those guys) is just the same as being black and acting "black" to be cool.

On another note, I was watching the film "The Pianist" a few weeks ago. Excellent film, and seeing a re-enactment of the Holocaust got me thinking to all these people who compare Republicans to Nazis in their belief regarding homosexuals. I thought, "Look, it's not like we're putting them in ghettos and making them wear something to single them out from everyone else...oh wait." I realized that that was what was happening - but it wasn't the government doing it, it was the people themselves. In a quest for individuality and unity among their own, the different minority groups had inadvertingly done to themselves what the Nazis did to the Jews in the early 1930's. They had allowed themselves to be separated and had further worstened it by singling themselves out. Granted, part of this was historical, with poor minorities crowding into the poorer sections of cities, and segregation had some part in it, but it seems to have grown worse. What does it mean when Kanye West can say on TV "My people are suffering in New Orleans" and not mean all the Americans? What does it mean when homosexuals wear their orientation on their sleeve? And what does it mean when any group has to live as a stereotype and not as an individual?

The thing that shocked the world in the 1930's and made what was happening to the Jews so repugnant was that before they were an accepted part in our society. Hitler himself admitted that he saw Jews everywhere, even places he would never expect them. By separating them and labeling them they dehumanized the Jews - they were no longer Germans. Theodore Roosevelt long ago warned against "hyphenated Americans" and was worried if America did not assimilate the way she was supposed to we would become nothing more than a "tangle of squabbling nationalities." It's OK to be black, gay, of Mexican descent, or whatever! Let's cut all the rubbish and remember we are all Americans, first and foremost.