Showing posts with label Donald Rumsfeld. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Donald Rumsfeld. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

Lost in Translation

Recently Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld made a speech before the American Legion, which I quoted in the comic above. The response to the speech by the talking heads in the media and many people on the left has astounded me - astounding me because of how terribly misconstrued it's been. Some people claim Rumsfeld called anti-war people "fascists," while others claim he's said the anti-war crowd is morally and intellectually confused. Those are both very different from Rumsfeld's original words.

In the movie "Patton" there's a scene where the title character is speaking to a group of old British ladies. He says casually that American and British relations are important, as America and Britain are destined to rule the world. The film cuts to a news reel saying that Patton said America and Britain would rule the world and leave out the Russians, with analysts calling for Patton being removed from his post. The film cuts to Patton telling a friend that he meant nothing of the sort, and that all he was trying to do was be nice to the little old ladies. I don't know if the events in this sequence are true to what really happened, but my mind immediately thought of this upon hearing all the commotion about Rumsfeld's speech. People seem to forget little facts like the fact Rumsfeld was speaking to the American Legion, a group of veterans of America's wars including World War II, and was probably just trying to make a connection for them between the struggles of our past and our struggles today. While I do not support Rumsfeld fully, my reaction here is to how people took the speech and how it was reported, not who gave it.

Some coworkers pointed to a speech by Keith Olbermann on his MSNBC Countdown, explaining to me that it summed up nicely the feelings of people who were against the war. I watched it, and quite frankly from start to finish I was shocked by it - I could not believe how seriously it was blowing what Rumsfeld said entirely out of proportion.

Using a transcript from the MSNBC website, I'll analyze what Olbermann said and why I think it is a prime example of taking something out of context, as well as just being all around a poor statement:

The man who sees absolutes where all other men see nuances and shades of meaning is either a profit or a quack. Donald H. Rumsfeld is not a prophet. We end the COUNTDOWN where we began, our No. 1 story with a special comment on Mr. Rumsfeld's remarkable speech to the American Legion yesterday. It demands the deep analysis and the sober contemplation of every American, for it did not merely serve to impugn the morality or intelligence, indeed the loyalty of the majority of Americans who impose the transient occupants of the highest offices in the land.

Worst still, it credits those same transient occupants, our employees, with a total omniscience, a total omniscience which neither commonsense nor this administration‘s track record, at home or abroad, suggest they deserve it. Descent and disagreement with government is the life's blood of human freedom and not merely because it the first roadblock against the kind of tyranny the men Mr. Rumsfeld likes to think his troops still fight this very evening in Iraq. It is also essential, because just every once in a while, it is right and the power to which it speaks is wrong.

Right here we can see already what we are getting into. Olbermann claims that Rumsfeld is lambasting those who criticize the war, when in fact Rumsfeld did no such thing. Rumsfeld was not calling any one fascist, nor was he directly claiming any one was intellectually or morally confused. What Rumsfeld was trying to say was we have a real enemy, and we cannot allow ourselves to get distracted from the task at hand. A staunch pacifist may say, "War is bad," but the hijackers on 9-11 did not care if any of the people in the planes were pacifists, nor did they care if any of them might sympathize with Arabs. Their only concern was hurting Americans and terrorizing our populace - that is the kind of enemy we're up against. While "war is bad" is good for peacetime and when matters can be solved through diplomacy, it's a moral confusion to think it always works against every scenario.

It is irony to note that Olbermann uses the phrase "likes to think his troops still fight" in regards to how Rumsfeld perceives the war. Irony because this is the kind of intellectual confusion Rumsfeld was probably talking about. It's the idea we may not be fighting against a tyranny, although most of the people we are fighting in Iraq are not, by any means, "the good guys." They are fundamentalist groups that blow up the holy buildings of other faiths and behead people they do not approve of. People like the late Zarqawi are not fighting for any type of "cause" other than that of a distorted view of Islam that is used to oppress people and enforce the rule of religious leaders. Maybe we are not fighting a tyranny right now, but we are fighting is a tyranny that might be. A theological Iraq, in which people of different faiths and ethnicities exist, would be disastrous and would lead to genocide to rival that of Saddam Hussein. While I would support someone who was merely against the war, I could never sympathize with someone who considered the insurgents good people simply because they didn't approve of the war and don't like Bush. This "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" logic is the kind of intellectual confusion Rumsfeld is warning against.
In a small irony however, Mr. Rumsfeld speech writer was adroit in invoking the memory of the appeasement of the Nazis for in their time, there was another government faced with true peril with a growing evil, powerful, and remorseless. That government, like Mr. Rumsfeld's, had a monopoly on all the facts. It too had the secret information, it alone had the true picture of the threat. It too, dismissed and insulted its critics in terms like Mr. Rumsfeld‘s. Questioning their intellect and their morality.

That government was England‘s in the 1930. It knew Hitler posed in true threat to Europe, let alone to England. It knew Germany was not re-arming in violation of all treaties and accords. It knew that the hard evidence it had received, which contradicted its own policies, its own conclusions, its own omniscient, needed to be dismissed.

The English government of Neville Chamberlain already knew the truth. Most relevant of all, it knew that its staunchest critics need to be marginalized and isolated, in fact it portrayed the foremost of them as a blood-thirsty warmonger who was, if not truly senile, at best morally or intellectually confused. That critics name was Winston Churchill.

Actually, Mister Olbermann, the Allied governments overestimated the Nazis. The only person who thought Nazi Germany was a threat to no one was Hitler himself, who had been advised by his generals that the armies of France and Czechoslovakia alone outnumbered the German army 2:1. It is also important to remember at the time that European governments had gone through World War I, which had cost hundreds of thousands of lives, and many people did not want another war because it would mean similar costs. It is also interesting to note that there was some sympathy for the Germans, who many felt were merely regaining their land lost after World War I. There was also still some respect for Hitler on the international level, especially since he was against the Communists. (and, after all, the enemy of my enemy is my friend...)

It is also interesting to note that for a while Britain and France thought there might be a war. Both France and Britain began to rearm themselves, Britain especially so - after World War I they had found themselves heavily in debt and the military's budget had been cut. Chamberlain, however, believed that all issues could be resolved diplomatically, and was happy when Hitler finally gave in and accepted the agreement at Munich.

I can see the point he's trying to make here: Chamberlain and his government (supposedly) knew the real information and thought they knew best, and so prevented people from knowing anything contrary to the truth and criticized people who disagreed with them. However, what always confuses me about his logic is what Rumsfeld and Churchill both stood for. Chamberlain was for appeasement and trying to make your enemies happy with diplomacy. Rumsfeld is against appeasement and thinks you need to use your military sometimes to make people realize you mean business. The person in World War II who would have most likely agreed with Rumsfeld was...Churchill, who Olbermann glorifies. Huh? I hope people understand where I'm coming from with this.

Sadly we have no Winston Churchill's evidence among this evening, we have only Donald Rumsfeld‘s demonizing disagreement, the way Neville Chamberlain demonized Winston Churchill. History and 163 million pounds of bombs over England have taught us that all Mr. Chamberlain had was his certainty and his own confusion, a confusion that suggested that the office cannot only make the man, but that the office can make the facts.

And once again, he claims Rumsfeld is "demonizing disagreement." He doesn't really quote Rumsfeld too much, merely makes these claims...probably because in reality he cannot quote Rumsfeld, because nothing Rumsfeld says is "demonizing disagreement."

But back to today's omniscient ones, that about what Mr. Rumsfeld is confused is simply this, this is a democracy, still, sometimes just barely and as such, all voices count, not just his. Had he or his president perhaps proven any of their prior claims of omniscience, about Osama bin Laden's plans five years ago, about Saddam Hussein's weapons four year, ago, about Hurricane Katrina's impact one year ago, we all might be able to swallow hard and except their omniscience as a bearable, even useful recipe of fact plus ego.

But to date, this government has proved little besides its own arrogance and its own hubris. Mr. Rumsfeld is also personally confused, morally or intellectually, about his standing in this matter. From Iraq to Katrina, to flu vaccine shortages to the entire fog of fear which continues to envelopes our nation, he, Mr. Bush, Mr. Cheney and their cronies have inadvertently or intentionally profited and benefited, both personally and politically.

First off, I have to say I'm amused when he says "this is a democracy, still, sometimes just barely." I suppose America is comparable to other "just barely" democracies like Iran where opposition voices are arrested or left to fend for themselves against government-incited mobs. Or, since Olbermann likes World War II so much, maybe even Hitler's "just barely" democracy, since the Nazis were "elected" into office. Then again, one wonders how long people like Keith Olbermann would have lasted in Nazi Germany?

Second, he goes down a rather cliche road with his points of omniscience. Osama bin Laden: how much was known? Our government has since learned how to deal with planned terrorist attacks, but of course this is always turned around against them. Al Qaeda has a habit of planning something, leaving it alone a long time, then updating it at the last minute just before it's carried out. When it was done again in 2004 and the government called out police and national guard units in New York City, the response was not, "Wow, good job government!" the response was "This is a ploy to win public favor" and "This is stupid - the Al Qaeda plan was planned years ago!" Imagine if the attacks had been carried out - what would have happened then? You would have had Keith Olbermann on MSNBC saying, "Where's your omniscience now?" As for the weapons, so few people realize even Saddam Hussein thought he had weapons. He ruled a Stalin-like dictatorship where failure meant torture or death; just as Stalin's men lied to him about the production of food, so too did Hussein's men lie to him about the conditions of the military and the progression of weapons of mass destruction. As for Hurricane Katrina, I have no idea how the administration was supposed to show omniscience about it when the Louisiana state governor said, "We don't need help," then just as the hurricane hits gives the oh-so-specific order of "Gimme everything you got."

I also don't see how the administration has profited. Bush's approval ratings are still pretty low, and most reasons are Iraq or Katrina, so how Olbermann sees this as a victory for Bush I have no idea.

And yet he can stand up in public and question the morality and the intellect of those of us who dare ask just the receipt for the emperor new clothes.

In what country was Mr. Rumsfeld raised? As a child at whose heroism did he read? On what side of the battle for freedom did he dream one day to fight? With what country has he confused the United States of America?

The confusion, we as its citizens must now address, is stark and forbidding. But variations of it have faced our forefathers when men like Nixon and McCarthy and Curtis Lemay have darkened our skies and obscured our flag.

This is where Olbermann begins to "preach to the converted" - basically, he's talking about stuff he knows people who already agree with him will bite and chew on. Once again he's misconstruing what Rumsfeld said - never directly quoting him, mind you, only taking words and phrases to twist them around and make them mean what he wants them to mean.

As for questioning what country Rumsfeld was raised in or which heroes he admired - that is all simply absurd, especially given that I've already pointed none of what Rumsfeld said has any major baring on anything.

Note, with hope in your heart, that those earlier Americans always found their way to the light and we can too. The confusion is about whether this secretary of defense and this administration are in fact now accomplishing what they claim the terrorists seek, the destruction of our freedoms, the very ones for which the same veterans Mr. Rumsfeld addressed yesterday in Salt Lake City so valiantly fought.

And about Mr. Rumsfeld‘s other main assertion of that this country faces a new type of fascism as he was correct to remind us that a government that knew everything could get everything wrong. So too was he right when he said that. Though probably not in the way he thought he meant. This country faces a new type of fascism, indeed.

Give me a break. I'm serious here. "The destruction of our freedoms?" As my dad once asked: how much have we (as common Americans) had to sacrifice since September 11? Higher gas prices? Is that really it? If our freedoms were being destroyed, why is Michael Moore allowed to make films making wild claims about the government and corporations? Why is Ted Rall allowed to print comics that not only demonize the administration, but slanders the reputation of our soldiers fighting and dying for his freedom to do so? When I point this out to people on the left and ask why the "dictator" hasn't done anything, they always respond, "It could happen." Yes, it could happen, but a lot of things could happen. Whether or not it will happen depends on the facts. I went to a Barnes and Nobles recently, there were slews of books criticizing Bush. There are countless websites criticizing Bush, from logical arguments against the war to childish rants. So you cannot tell me, in the face of all this free speech, our freedoms are somehow being intruded upon. The best people can tell me is "Oh, well, some people call critics of the war cowards." That's not intruding on your freedoms, that's called being a jerk. I have been called a "sheep" for supporting the war, does that mean my freedoms are being taken away?

While Michael Moore fans claim he faces censorship and conspiracies from the government, German filmmaker Fritz Lang had to leave his home country because the Nazis were banning his films and threatening his life. While artists make "statements" claiming our leader's a tyrant, German artists Hitler deemed "decadent" were rounded up and sent to concentration camps. While gays and lesbians in America complain that they can live together but just can't marry, homosexuals in Iran are arrested and executed. While "If These Walls Could Talk," a film about the question of abortion, came out in America, women in Afghanistan worried if they would get stoned to death for showing a little wrist. So yes, Mister Olbermann, we're facing a new form of fascism, but the fascism is not us.

Although I use his sign off each night in feeble tribute, I have utterly no claims to the words of the exemplary journalist, Edward R. Murrow. But never in the trial of 1,000 years of writing could I come close to matching how he phrased a warning to an earlier generation of us, at a time when other polarities thought they and they alone knew everything and branded those who disagreed confused or immoral.

Thus for give me for reading Murrow in full.

“We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty” he said in 1954, “We must remember always that accusation is not proof and that conviction depends upon evidence and due process of law. We will not walk in fear one of another. We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine, and remember that we are not disended from fearful men, not from men who fear to write, to speak, to associate and to defend causes that were, for the moment, unpopular. And so, goodnight and good luck.”

This is, quite frankly, rubbish, ending on a poetic note to sound good, although I will give Mister Olbermann credit for saying he doesn't think himself on equal with Edward Murrow. While I approve of someone ending a speech or a statement on a good note, this only shows me that Rumsfeld's words did nothing except give the talking heads of the media something to fill in empty air time with.

Murrow was facing different threats. Rumsfeld is not standing in a Senate committee pointing to government, community, and military leaders and asking, "Are you now, or have you ever been, a member of a terrorist party?" He's not criticizing the critics of the war on terror as individuals: he was speaking of intellectual or moral confusion as nouns, not adjectives. Rumsfeld was trying to warn people, "Yes, we're facing a deep threat, and we have to realize that." If you disagree with HOW the government is fighting the war on terror, then yes that is fine. Let it be known I have openly stated I support criticism of the government. However, if you're asking IS there a war against terror, then you have no grasp of world events and what has transpired over the past few decades.

Although I'm ending this blog entry on feeble tribute, I have utterly no claims to the words of the exemplary politician, Winston Churchill. But never in the trial of 1,000 years of writing could I come close to matching how he phrased a warning to an earlier generation of us, at a time when a great threat faced the world.

Thus forgive me for quoting Winston Churchill in full:

In this solemn hour it is a consolation to recall and to dwell upon our repeated efforts for peace. All have been ill-starred, but all have been faithful and sincere. This is of the highest moral value--and not only moral value, but practical value--at the present time, because the wholehearted concurrence of scores of millions of men and women, whose co-operation is indispensable and whose comradeship and brotherhood are indispensable, is the only foundation upon which the trial and tribulation of modern war can be endured and surmounted. This moral conviction alone affords that ever-fresh resilience which renews the strength and energy of people in long, doubtful and dark days. Outside, the storms of war may blow and the lands may be lashed with the fury of its gales, but in our own hearts this Sunday morning there is peace. Our hands may be active, but our consciences are at rest.

We must not underrate the gravity of the task which lies before us or the temerity of the ordeal, to which we shall not be found unequal. We must expect many disappointments, and many unpleasant surprises, but we may be sure that the task which we have freely accepted is one not beyond the compass and the strength of the British Empire and the French Republic. The Prime Minister said it was a sad day, and that is indeed true, but at the present time there is another note which may be present, and that is a feeling of thankfulness that, if these great trials were to come upon our Island, there is a generation of Britons here now ready to prove itself not unworthy of the days of yore and not unworthy of those great men, the fathers of our land, who laid the foundations of our laws and shaped the greatness of our country.

This is not a question of fighting for Danzig or fighting for Poland. We are fighting to save the whole world from the pestilence of Nazi tyranny and in defense of all that is most sacred to man. This is no war of domination or imperial aggrandizement or material gain; no war to shut any country out of its sunlight and means of progress. It is a war, viewed in its inherent quality, to establish, on impregnable rocks, the rights of the individual, and it is a war to establish and revive the stature of man. Perhaps it might seem a paradox that a war undertaken in the name of liberty and right should require, as a necessary part of its processes, the surrender for the time being of so many of the dearly valued liberties and rights. In these last few days the House of Commons has been voting dozens of Bills which hand over to the executive our most dearly valued traditional liberties. We are sure that these liberties will be in hands which will not abuse them, which will use them for no class or party interests, which will cherish and guard them, and we look forward to the day, surely and confidently we look forward to the day, when our liberties and rights will be restored to us, and when we shall be able to share them with the peoples to whom such blessings are unknown.