Angelo Santino asking an innocent question. I wonder why it isn't asked more often?This comic was inspired by an episode of ABC World News (not to be confused with ABC Nightline, which is now tabloid TV) in which they ran a story discussing how it was hotter now than it had been in a million years. What Angelo asks in the comic is what every one should ask: how hot was it a million years ago? The simple answer is we don't know. I have never supported the global warming idea (I refuse to call it a "theory") because, quite frankly, I've never seen enough evidence to support it. Some of my readers may be wondering how I got this point of view. "What's the matter with you?" some might ask, "The earth has been warming up in the past ten years! It's so obvious! And all the scientists agree!"
One has to be careful when dealing with what scientists say, however. I once read a New York Times editorial that said no scientist except those under the paycheck of "the energy companies" (more on that statement later) disagrees with the notion that the earth has been warming. This is a tricky statement, because it's really a half-truth. No scientist denies the earth hasn't been warming because there has been a slight increase in global temperatures worldwide. However, there is disagreement among scientists as to WHY the temperatures increased. Many of those scientists that support the idea only do so because they need the funding, or don't want to be singled out. As William K. Stevens, author of The Change in the Weather: People, Weather and the Science of Climate, explains on page 242, "many do not speak out because it doesn't pay...the climate issue has drawn a lot of government funding." Marcel Leroux, a French climatologist, went on to say in his book Global Warming: Myth or Reality? that the majority voice is abused by many scientific groups to single out those who disagree or may have conflicting evidence. "The mere weight of numbers," Leroux writes on page 5, "may control and dismiss discordant voices from publications and papers." A recorded incident of this was when the IPCC (the UN body regarding climate change) held a meeting at the Moscow Academy of Sciences at 2004, and rejected some scientists because of being "climato-skeptics." These scientists were not even staunch critics of global warming, merely individuals who disapproved of global warming ideas in their field. One of the men rejected, entomologist Paul Reiter, disagrees with the notion that bugs will be spread by global warming alone as there is evidence that many insects lived in various regions of the world in past centuries.
What is the real problem with global warming? Marcel Leroux lays it out nicely in his already mentioned book, listing a few key issues:
- Pollution and climate - Meaning, the relationship between the two. Marcel Leroux warns that because of all the silly notions coming down from the global warming supporters regarding climate, climatology is in danger of being hijacked by the global warming cause and turned into a joke. He uses the metaphor of the boy who cried wolf.
- Good intentions versus declared/undeclared interests - the idea that every critic of global warming is a pawn of energy companies, including the "oil barons," is just as flawed as thinking every supporter of global warming is looking out for the environment. There are good and bad people on both sides. I can certainly promise you I am not receiving a hefty check from Exxon-Mobile for writing this blog entry.
- Theories within models versus real mechanisms - What Leroux means here is, quite simply, what people think and what really happens. This is where you get into a lot of the global warming idea's major flaws, as scientists predict one thing and we find another happening. Later on I will discuss the ever popular notion that hurricanes are caused by global warming.
- Sensationalism versus serious science - this is where we get into the good stuff like "it's the hottest its been in a million years!" or "Hurricane Katrina was caused by global warming!" Marcel Leroux makes the point that for many scientists the goal is "not to inform, but to impress." You're not going to get coverage on ABC World News by saying we have no way of knowing how hot the temperature was a million years ago, so why bother?
You might now be saying, "What about the evidence for it? All the carbon gas and records!" You have to be careful there as well. S. Fred Singer, one of the staunchest critics of global warming, has made two big criticisms that have been conceded by his opponents. (Stevens, 246) For one, we are not entirely sure about the fate of human-created carbon dioxide once it hits the atmosphere, ie how long it's there, where it goes, when does it take on the next step in the carbon cycle, etc. He also points out that much of the instruments used for measuring global warming are flawed. Computer models give varying results, arbitrary adjustments are needed to get what you want, and clouds are poorly modeled. Much "evidence" is, in fact, really circumstantial. People say, "The earth is warming," but there's no visible connection between carbon emissions and temperature change. People say "The polar ice caps are melting!" but there is record evidence of the polar ice caps melting greatly 500 years ago. (Changes in the Wind by Margery and Howard Facklam, pg 67) Usually the evidence is supposed to lead to a conclusion, but here it seems like the conclusion is leading to the evidence. In other words, people are looking at it in a biased way. You might compare this to a police investigator being assigned a murder, and instead of looking for clues to point to the murderer he decides ahead of time who he thinks did it and looks for clues to support that claim. It's not how investigative science works, and it shouldn't be how climatology works.
You might say, "Yes, but the earth is still warming! You can't dispute that! And look, everyone drives cars!" True, but there is nothing to connect the change to human activity. Some scientists even believe that the warming could be a natural cycle the earth goes through. I've had people argue with me that there is a history of the earth cooling down, but its only because of outside forces like volcanoes or meteorite showers. While it is true that certain events cause the earth to cool down (just as certain events cause the earth to warm up - more on that later) this is overlooking some of the major changes the earth has gone through. For example, what would one call the Ice Age? Did the ice melt because the mammoths all started driving cars? There is also a time period between the 1400's and 1700's that is known as "the Little Ice Age." As explained in Changes in the Wind, it was during this period that the earth faced harsher winters than it ever had before. There is archeological evidence that Native Americans in the midwest United States moved south during this time period because of the harsher winters, and during this time period the Baltic Sea turned to ice and Boston Harbor completely froze up.
An interesting side-story happened when I was debating this with some friends at college. They had just gone through a discussion about a documentary talking about how the Ice Age had melted within the span of five years. When we started to talk about global warming and I said that the earth could be going through a natural phase, they said the earth had never warmed up this fast. I immediately reminded them that just a few minutes ago they had said the Ice Age only took five years to melt away. Even they had to admit there was some merit to that point. I was also happy to see most of them thought the "global warming causes hurricanes" notion was rubbish.
People argue, "But there are more hurricanes now than there ever were before!" This is jumping to assumptions, and is a classic example of what Marcel Leroux called Sensationalism versus Serious Science. Hurricanes start in the Sahel Region near Africa, and depending on how moist or dry the region is will determine how frequent and powerful hurricanes are. In 1970 a drought occurred in the Sahel Region, thus during this time hurricanes were less powerful and occurred less than before. This drought ended in the early 1990's, and scientists predicted that hurricanes would occur more frequently and be more powerful. (Stevens, 117) In other words, Hurricane Katrina was not the result of global warming because we saw storms like it coming long before the new millennium. Sensationalist science says it's global warming - serious science says it's just nature. Even more humorously, this past year has seen little hurricane activity outside from hurricanes that are born and die in the Atlantic Ocean. Only a few have made landfall, but we have not seen a second Katrina as predicted by serious global warming believers such as Al Gore. Granted, this hasn't stopped the sensationalized media coverage. I remember when Tropical Storm Ernesto came by my area recently - I think this tropical storm got more coverage than pre-landfall Hurricane Katrina did.
This leads me to my final point, which is the excuse given for failures in the global warming idea. The simple answer to solve all issues is: "natural variation." When the world cooled in 1996, global warming scientists quickly stated that "a global warming trend would not be expected to be smooth and continuous...one can get cooler years or even cooler decades owing to natural variation." (Stevens, 166) Cooler decades are "natural variation?" In my opinion, this is a great Catch-22 for global warming: when the world gets hotter it's global warming, when it gets colder it's natural variation. Consider, for example, that many of the hot days in cities or regions are naturally explainable by studying the weather. The city of Norfolk where I live recently went through a hot spell not because of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere but because of a jet stream pushing away cold air from the eastern United States. Once the jet stream left things cooled down. A record setting Sunday in March 1998 over Bermuda was caused by an anti-cyclone, which blows cold and warm air throughout regions continually. Warm air was blown into the region, caused the hot day, and within a week the hot air was moved out and temperatures returned to normal. (Stevens, 107) The year 1997's increase in temperature was attributed to the storm El Nino, not global warming. As Marcel Leroux wrote in an article for the French magazine Fusion, "some regions are getting warmer, but others are just as surely cooling down." You cannot talk about global climate because there is no "global" climate, only "a large variety of climates, depending on latitude, geographic conditions, and atmospheric dynamics."
It's not that I don't think pollution is bad. I do think we should control emissions because we've seen short-range consequences to condensed carbon dioxide around major cities: smog, acid rain, what have you. However, the idea that climate is actually being affected needs to be further studied, and we should not rule out any other explanation. Some may say, "Well, better safe than sorry," or, "It's good people are trying to stop polluting," but millions of dollars are being spent on funding that could be better used elsewhere. There have been many conspiracy theories in the past regarding what will become of our earth: in the 1970's people thought we were heading to another Ice Age; in the 80's and 90's we were worried about the hole in the o-zone until it started healing itself up; now we're worried about a great human-made force that will heat up the world, fry all animal and plant life, melt the ice caps, and cause daily hurricanes.
Al Gore, in a TV interview, compared the critics of global warming to people in the Middle Ages who thought the world was flat. I'd say we're more like the people in the Renaissance who said the earth rotated around the sun, rather than the popular belief that everything rotated around the earth. If we're truly worried about what is warming the earth, then let's try to find an explanation for it rather than flatly saying "global warming" and refusing to argue the point. An arrogant, opinionated stance is not the way science works.
