A lot of hoopla has been made about the recent troop surge to Iraq. You have Democrats in congress opposing it every step of the way with non-binding resolutions, (and some more binding ones) and if you tune into any major news source you'll hear about the percentage of Americans who oppose the surge. The talking heads on TV are rattling on with, "How is this surge any different than past ones? This is just throwing more men into the meat grinder!"Oddly enough, this is more than a surge. These men on the ground will be put to good use rooting out the insurgents where they hide, dismantling their leadership and most of all making sure that they cannot regain that ground. We've seen a precedent in the past where as soon as Iraqi or Coalition troops enter an area the people cooperate and tell them where the bad men hide. They won't cooperate if they know the insurgents will be back by nightfall to behead any one who doesn't follow their faith or cooperated with the government.
Part of this I blame on the president for not making it clear enough that this is more than a troop surge, while I also blame the media for only reporting it as "another" troop surge and nothing else. When reported like this it makes it sound like we've always sent troops into Iraq. The truth is we haven't. The past few months before the surge began, for example, we had been withdrawing troops. Violence in Iraq grew after that. (a good guide to that can be found right here at the BBC) The effectiveness of a surge may be debatable, but the effectiveness of withdrawing troops is not.
I support the troop surge for a variety of reasons, the main one being that this surge actually has a plan behind it. This isn't just tossing more men at the problem; the days of "stay the course" are long gone. (thank God for that!) These men will be put to use bringing the war to where the insurgents hide and making sure any ground we take won't be lost again. It is also good that we are working together with the Iraqi forces to help them get on their feet, get the supplies they need, and make sure they're able to work with civilians to stop those who would do harm to the country. I'm also happy to hear that American forces can now arrest or engage Iranian agents who have infiltrated the country to help militants. These are two excellent developments for the war in Iraq.
The negative response to the surge is, in my personal opinion, very premature. It is a gut reaction rather than one found after careful thought. The Democratic congress has not reacted to the positive outcome the surge could provide, but instead the fact the surge is happening. Even Senator Chuck Hagel of Nebraska, the sole Republican to join Democrats in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in their non-binding resolution, made the statement, "We better be damn sure we know what we're doing." It seems to me from all reports on the military and political levels that we know darn well what we're doing.
This is a cliche question, but one that I think needs to be asked: what alternative to this plan has Congress presented? Practically none except, "It's a bad idea." They're statement after the 2007 State of the Union was that the president would no longer be in charge, but thus far that seems to simply mean they'll be a thorn in the president's side from here on end. We've only heard suggestions of alternative plans, and most of them bad:
- Pull out - Pulling out for the sake of pulling out is a disastrous idea. It's been said countless times, but pulling out now would leave an Iraq worse off than it is right now. In one scenario an Al Qaeda friendly government takes over and they gain another safe haven. In another scenario Iran sets up a puppet government, which would be bad for everyone in the Middle East. (Iran truly has few allies in the region) I am not entirely against troop withdrawal, but I am against troop withdrawal with no strategic purpose.
- Cut funds or supplies to the Iraqi government - Even worse idea! Particularly when most Iraqi military leaders are saying they desperately need supplies and support. You can't take away a person's lifeline when they can't even get their feet off the ground.
"In 1973 the situation looked hopeful for the South Vietnamese. The ARVN was over one million strong and was the recipient of the very latest US weaponry...the communists, though, still smarting from their recent defeats, had only 150,000 troops in South Vietnam. In addition the communist supply lines lay in ruins. The ARVN was in a dominant position...We all know what happened after that - 60,000 South Vietnamese were murdered by the communists, followed by most being sent to re-education camps, others being sent to prison and kept there even until the mid-1990's. In neighboring Cambodia Pol Pot took command and over 30% of the population was lost in what became known as "the killing fields." People on the extreme left love to talk about how much this war is like Vietnam. Well, if it is, then it works both ways...but I doubt they would readily admit to this.
In Washington, though, Congress passed the War Powers Act that called for congressional approval of any overseas troop deployment - effectively ending any hope that Nixon might have had regarding future military aid to Vietnam. Matters worsened in August 1974 when Nixon resigned over the Watergate scandal, to be replaced in office by President Gerald Ford. With no true mandate to govern Ford would not call for US troops to re-enter Vietnam. The South Vietnamese regime was on their own...
In 1973 the United States sent 2.3 billion dollars in aid to South Vietnam and cut aid to only 1.1 billion dollars in 1974. The drop in aid caused the South Vietnamese economy to implode. Inflation shot up over 200%, destroying the fledgling South Vietnamese middle class and causing widespread poverty and unrest...As a result American aid, though significant, no longer even covered the costs of the ARVN, leading to a shortage of fuel, ammunition, and spare parts for their ultra-modern array of weaponry. By the end of the year the ARVN had lost its firepower edge over the NVA and even much of its mobility...South Vietnam had not been made into a viable nation but the US had succeeded in exiting the war...By late 1974 the North Vietnamese had recovered from their losses in 1972 and stood ready to attack..." (pg. 80-81)
There is actually much hypocrisy here. For the longest time we have heard, "There weren't enough troops in Iraq" when people talked about the problems there. Now that more troops are being sent, and being sent to perform an important job, suddenly that's a grave mistake. Actually, anti-war people often contradict themselves, one minute arguing there are too many troops, then the next minute arguing there aren't enough troops. (just as before the invasion they would staunchly argue that Saddam had WMD's because America gave them to him, then turn around and staunchly argue Saddam didn't have WMD's)
You also have to enjoy the stubbornness of the new political leaders in regards to the needs of our military. We keep hearing people on the left say, "Just let the generals do their job!" or "We'll let the military do what they want." What they really mean is, "We want the generals to do what we want them to do." When the Democrats took over Congress they asked the generals if pulling out was an option - they were told it was a bad option. In the face of the surge most military commanders in Iraq agree that it is a good plan, and a long overdue one at that. Despite this, the Democrats are still against it. I support a civilian-controlled military (that's one of the bases for democracy) but I also think this makes it clear that no matter who is in control of the government, the generals will always be told how to do their job.
I could go on about this, but I think I've said enough. I'll end with a special note to all those soldiers, sailors, and otherwise going overseas: good lock, God bless, and God speed. You are in our prayers, and you have our thanks: you are serving your country because we aren't, and that is something every American civilian - pro-military or anti-military - takes for granted.
