Showing posts with label Hezbollah. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hezbollah. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Poor Little Lebanon

Lebanon, a nation once thought of as the most beautiful of the Middle East, seems these days unable to get any kind of break. And I mean that not as a sarcastic remark, but a show of sympathy and great respect to the Lebanese people themselves.

The nation is often caught in the middle between Israel and militant Muslim groups (at first the PLO, and then Hezbollah) as well as a victim of Syria's power plays. Now the most recent violence is within the refugee camp Nahr al-Bared, just outside Tripoli. The violence was started when a Palestinian group called Fatah al-Islam exchanged fire with the Lebanese army. Four members of the group robbed a bank, got about $63,000 worth of money, and escaped into the refugee camp. When Lebanese security officials moved into the camp to arrest them, the terrorist group opened fire. The army responded by shelling the camp and assaulting their positions. There is, at the point of this writing, an uneasy cease-fire as the two sides negotiate - a cease-fire most likely to be broken when one group aggravates the other.

Fatah al-Islam is fairly new to the scene, with manpower just under 200. They emerged in November, 2006, breaking away from the Syrian-backed Palestinian group Fatah al-Infitada. Previously four members were arrested and "confessed to the twin bus bombings in February that killed three people in a Christian area near the capital." Their leader, Shakir al-Abssi, has been sentenced to death in absentia by a Jordanian court for the murder of American ambassador Laurence Foley in 2002. The group, like many Jihadist groups, seeks power within their nation, the removal of all western influence, confrontation with Israel, and the enforcement of Sharia law. The Lebanese government has claimed that Syria backs the group, although Syria has claimed that the group is wanted in Syria for terrorist activities. Fatah al-Islam has also come under criticism for it's loose connections with Al Qaeda. Although it does not confess any direct connection to Al Qaeda, "experts point to Fatah al-Islam as one of the range of armed Islamist groups independent of Al Qaeda in terms of logistics and finances, but sharing Al Qaeda's aims and ideology." Al-Abssi did, however, admit links with Zarqawi, the Al Qaeda leader in Iraq. Whatever the organization's official stance, many Palestinian militant groups (including Hamas) have already distanced themselves from the organization.

Lebanon's Prime Minister Fouad Siniora has vowed he will not "surrender to terrorism" and has called the group a criminal gang hiding behind Islam and the Palestinian cause. He has, however, said that the militants would be treated fairly if they surrendered. The international response to this has been surprisingly pro-Lebanese government, from western and Arab governments alike. The United States donated military supplies to the Lebanese that amounted to "ammunition for automatic rifles and heavy weapons, spare parts for military helicopters and night-vision equipment." A Red Cross convoy came from Amman, Jordan and assisted refugees within the camps, and has delivered much needed water, food, and medicine. The United Arab Emirates also sent military aide to Lebanon.

There has been some relief for the people inside. The camp reportedly held about 31,000 people, and of these at least 25,000 people have been allowed to leave. Although this still leaves about 6,000 people inside, I think it says something for those involved with the evacuations, and if all hell breaks loose it will greatly reduce the amount of civilian casualties. In the meantime, Lebanon is allowing time for negotiations, with Prime Minister Siniora calling Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, Lebanese Defense Minister Elias Murr leaving room for political talks, and UN and Arab League representatives working with the Lebanese officials to handle the refugees.

I believe several things come into play here. One is the conflict between pro-Syrian and anti-Syrian leaders within Lebanon, perfectly represented in the fact Lebanon's prime minister is anti-Syrian while their president is pro-Syrian. There is the claim by the Lebanese government that this act is being encouraged by Syria to distract the government from forming a tribunal to look into the 2005 assassination of former prime minister Rafik Hariri. The deadlock between pro-Syrian and anti-Syrian groups has become so terrible that the UN Security Council has even suggested it may step in if need be.

Also keeping a close eye on all this, and also a part of the Syria-oriented struggle, is Hezbollah. The ever present Hassan Nasrallah has warned against storming the camp, even though he has said the fighters should be brought to justice and he would distance himself from them. He has also criticized the Lebanese government for what he says is dragging the country into America's war with Al Qaeda, mentioning the military aide from the United States. Siniora responded to criticism of the aide by accusing certain groups of wanting to weaken Lebanon's army to "justify the presense of other armies," most likely Syria's. If the incident turns into a victory for Siniora, it could make a boost in the government's support and hurt Hezbollah's standing among non-Shia Lebanese. With world support for Lebanon and her army, Siniora could turn it against Hezbollah, or use the political support to put pressure on Nasrallah to step in line. Then again, Nasrallah could just be a mouth-piece for his supporters in Syria and Iran, who wouldn't like further American influence in Lebanon.

Now, if the incident proves a loss for Siniora, then the results could be devastating for him and helpful for Nasrallah. There are over 400,000 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, scattered in many camps, and if further violence is incited then the nation would most likely find herself caught again in factional warfare. This would also allow Nasrallah to gain in popularity and allow Hezbollah to gain a stranglehold on the government. While it's unlikely Nasrallah and al-Abssi would join forces, (they are, after all, members of two different sects of Islam, and therefore consider one another enemies) embarrassing violence started by the government would be beneficial to either man. If it proves to be helpful to neither men, then a weakened Lebanese government could prove inspiring to other militant groups looking to make a foothold in the Middle East.

Because of this, the international community also has interest in this conflict. UNIFIL, for example, has become worried of an Al Qaeda presence in Lebanon, as has Israel. In December of 2005 an Al Qaeda cell fired Katyusha rockets across the south Lebanese border. Reports have also said Al Qaeda has been planning attacks against UNIFIL forces, and thus French, Italian, and Spanish soldiers in the area will be under great risk.

So the question is, where do we go from here? The obvious concern is the growth of terrorism within Lebanon, especially international terrorism such as Al Qaeda. It would not only destabilize Lebanon and perhaps lead to an increase in Syrian interests, but it would also cause greater chaos along the border with Israel. Therefore, this organization cannot be allowed to stay. However, an all out attack could prove bloody, messy, and a political disaster for the Lebanese government. With political and international support behind her, Lebanon may push for a peaceful surrender. This is very hopeful, however - with Fatah al-Islam refusing to surrender to the loyalists of "Zionist Americans," a military option may be the only option. This would also mean - very regrettably - further civilian casualties. Fatah al-Islam no doubt knows this, hence why, as a previously linked BBC story said, so many refugee camps have become a safe haven for militant groups. The Lebanese army is not allowed in, hence they are allowed to do as they please. Palestinian groups especially have been practicing this for decades, and in the last war between Hezbollah and Israel the Shia organization admitted openly that the practice of hiding behind civilians had proved politically beneficent.

Therefore, the Lebanese government must tread a careful line in their handling of this matter. They cannot allow the group to win, but they must review all options and their military must handle the matter as carefully as it can. It will, in the long term, be positive for the Lebanese nation and her people. Whatever happens, I long for a day when Lebanon and her people can finally rest peacefully, without their nation being the victim of regional powers.

Monday, April 02, 2007

Happy Birthday, Lion's Den!

The cartoon is a caricature of Martin Bashir, a journalist for ABC Nightline. He's probably the quintessential sleazy reporter you often see made fun of in movies and television shows.

It's hard to believe, but this blog is now one year old. I started it on Sunday, April 2, 2006 while I was a senior at college, opening with this introductory post and this "official" entry.

I'm happy it's still active after all this time, and I'd like to thank everyone - personal friends, forum-goers, and the occasional passerby - for contributing to the discussion for each topic, whether it was positive or negative.

I'd also like to share this e-mail conversation between myself and Lion's Den reader Josh:
Josh: "Are you still planning your terrorist plot to against Jewish holdings in Virginia in support of Hezbollah?"
Me: "Oh thanks Josh, now Homeland Security's going to go through my computer and find all my child-rape porn."
Josh: "Just doin' my part, man. lol"
Me: "I've just received word from Beirut. This is Woody Allen's last night on earth. VICTORY FOR HEZBOLLAH!"
And on that note, thanks again! Let's go for another whole year! Whoo! Yeah...

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

"The Price of a Free Press"

I drew this back when there was that conflict between Israel and Hezbollah, in mockery of how the media seemed to be covering nothing but this conflict.

Recently an article in the Jerusalem Post caught my eye as being well thought-out and well written regarding the modern media and its influence on conflict. Like the Jerusalem Post article on Saddam Hussein, it seemed to make a lot of points I agreed with and put it in words better than I could. I have linked it above, but I've edited it to what I think are the most interesting points below. (and so the lazy ones among you don't have to read the whole thing) Although it mainly deals with an Israeli perspective, it looks at various world situations as well, and I believe that the subject matter is something that could fit in any conflict.
An important study on last summer's war has just been published by the Joan Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government. It is the first to give a comprehensive explanation of how, in an asymmetrical war "between a state [Israel] and a militant, secretive, religiously fundamentalist sect or faction [Hizbullah]," the fight is just as much about information and image as it is about military gains...

Kalb writes that Lebanon was "the first really 'live' war in history...every aspect of warfare - the troops going in and out of the battlefield, bombs and missiles falling, the dead, the wounded, the refugees - was brought to viewers in real time, "as though the world had a front-row seat on the blood and gore of modern warfare."...

This stream of immediate images, seemingly without any filtering, would seem like a positive development - in principle enabling viewers to reach their own conclusions. But, as Kalb shows, the new coverage is anything but objective.

Miniaturization, wireless broadcasting and high-speed links enable news organizations to overcome technical obstacles. Censorship and intimidation, however, still remain. Which means that democratic societies living by the ideals of a free and unfettered press will always be at a disadvantage to dictatorships and oppressive ideologies, adept at manipulating the media. As Kalb writes: "A closed society conveys the impression of order and discipline; an open society, buffeted by the crosswinds of reality and rumor, criticism and revelation, conveys the impression of disorder, chaos and uncertainty."

Israel's campaign was remarkably transparent: Journalists achieved unprecedented levels of access to its forces...As a reporter who covered the war on all three fronts (Lebanon, Gaza and the quiet but tense Syrian front), I was not aware of any real effort on the part of the IDF to limit media access - except, perhaps, for the faceless clerks in the military censorship office who occasionally crossed out minor details in my reports. The only significant censorship I felt was my own, in the cases in which I realized that the timing of certain reports might put our forces in danger...

On the other side, Hizbullah controlled the journalists covering the situation in Lebanon with an iron fist. Media tours of Hizbullah-controlled areas, where the IDF's bombing was mainly concentrated, were tightly managed, with foreign reporters being sternly warned against wandering off and talking to local residents unsupervised. Infringement of these rules would be punished by the confiscation of cameras and disbarment from any further visits or access to Hizbullah members. According to Kalb, only CNN's Anderson Cooper openly admitted to having operated under these rules...

Another scene almost never shown was the hundreds of Hizbullah firing positions and missile launch sites within residential areas and private homes, the cause of many civilian deaths and a violation of international law...

These methods, Kalb writes, created "a narrative that depicted a selfless movement touched by God and blessed by a religious fervor and determination to resist the enemy, the infidel, and ultimately achieve a 'divine victory,' no matter the cost in life and treasure. The narrative contained no mention of Hizbullah's dependence upon Iran and Syria for a steady flow of arms and financial resources."

Not that there was any shortage of footage coming out of Lebanon. But it dealt almost exclusively with the results of the IDF bombing and the Lebanese civilian casualties. Few news organizations made an effort to balance these pictures with those of the damage from Hizbullah's indiscriminate bombing of Israeli civilians. Neither was any effort made to show that Israel's attacks were concentrated mainly on areas of Hizbullah activity, leaving the rest of Beirut and other Lebanese towns and cities relatively unscathed...

This style of coverage...turned the accusation of "disproportionality" made by Israel's critics into common media currency...

[Kalb] believes that we have entered a new media age in which the reporter has become the commentator and very often is himself a "part of the story."

This new reality has both positive and negative implications which are only now coming to light.

Most of the details in Kalb's paper were already known to media observers, though his keen analysis offers the first real perspective on this "information war."

Two crucial questions he raises have special relevance for the Israeli media. One is the prominence that every IDF screw-up received in the local media. The other is that the war's result was so inconclusive that it caused feelings of disappointment and anger among the public toward both the military and the political leadership.

There is no proof that the IDF made more mistakes or was in any way less professional than in past wars. What has changed is the media's viewpoint, thanks to official openness and modern technology...This week I interviewed a veteran paratrooper, one of the officers who led the assault on the Old City of Jerusalem in the Six Day War. "We made all the same mistakes then," he said. "The commanders were no better, probably even worse. It just wasn't reported."

How can the media balance between its duty to report failure and incompetence, which in many cases might remain neglected if not for the publicity, and the need to create a proper perspective from which to view the war?

Which leads us to the next question. In a confrontation in which information is a weapon, should a democracy curb freedom of the press when its adversary is craftily manipulating the media and utilizing every report in the free press as military intelligence? (Hizbullah had a special section that monitored every detail in the Israeli and international press, and passed on up-to-date information to its forces in the field.) Is the price of living in an open democracy too heavy in time of war? How can a free country put its case across to a free press?...

The unavoidable conclusion as Kalb sees it - and it is very difficult to argue with him - is that "in strictly military terms, Israel did not lose to Hizbullah in this war, but it clearly did not win. In the war of information, news and propaganda, the battlefield central to Hizbullah's strategy, Israel lost this war."

And he makes a worrisome prediction that the outcome on other battlefields of the war on terror could be similar. One of the most interesting quotes in his paper is from Col. David Kilcullen, an Australian counterinsurgency expert, who explains that when insurgents attack a US convoy in Iraq, "they are not doing that because they want to reduce the number of Humvees we have in Iraq by one. They're doing it because they want spectacular media footage of a burning Humvee. If [Osama] bin Laden didn't have access to global media, satellite communications and the Internet, he'd just be a cranky guy in a cave."

Wednesday, August 16, 2006

Shhh, Nasrallah's asleep!

This cartoon is based off the folk tale of the mice and the bell. In the story, a group of mice are plagued by a cat who is killing them off. They decide the best thing to do is to put a bell on the cat so they can hear him coming, but when it is asked who will actually put the bell on the cat no one answers. This morning I was trying to think of something that spoke about the whole situation in Lebanon, and this story immediately resurrected itself from my childhood.

With the peace treaty there's a lot of debate about who won. Did Israel win? Did Hezbollah win? Israel claims victory because they damaged Hezbollah and are going through with the UN treaty, while Hezbollah is claiming victory because they're still around and Israel is leaving. Hezbollah, of course, doesn't tell people that Israel is only leaving because they're following the UN cease-fire agreement that Israel, Lebanon, and even Hezbollah agreed to. I'm not particularly aware of an hour-by-hour report of the war, but I doubt there was any Lebanese form of Rorke's Drift in this conflict.

In my personal opinion, the one thing that will determine who "won" this war is how the cease-fire is carried out. If a UN buffer zone can be made between Israel and Lebanon, and Hezbollah is disarmed or at least effectively tamed, then Israel can claim a victory. This is what they were trying to accomplish all along. Don't forget that the cease-fire also entails that Israel will have their soldiers returned. Some people claim this is a defeat for Israel because they didn't accomplish any of their goals - but the cease-fire agreement gives them all their goals. It also saves Israel from losing face in international pressure for the conflict. So all in all, if the agreement can be carried out to a good degree then it is a victory for Israel.

What if it can't? What if nothing happens? What if it all starts over again? Is that a victory of Hezbollah? No, it's not. It's a defeat for the Lebanese people, who will really be the losers here. They will again become stuck between warring factions, one not even a major part of their government. I have to also add my own opinion of the UN will be diminished if they cannot carry this out right. Let's not forget one of the reasons we had this conflict was because the UN was supposed to disarm Hezbollah and set up a buffer zone between Israel and Lebanon a long time ago.

There are two obstacles I see to carrying out peace. The most obvious is whether or not Israel or Hezbollah can keep the peace. Although this may sound one-sided, I'm not very worried about Israel. Don't forget the restraint they showed in the face of Hamas' continual attacks, and currently the Israeli army is giving ground to the Lebanese army as part of the peace transition. Hezbollah will no doubt try to do something to enrage Israel and earn more public support, though for now they may be on the low. Cease-fire in Arab/Muslim history have always been about rebuilding yourself and getting ready for the next attack. Mohammed himself used this tactic against enemies, and even in Israeli history you can see this: during the War of Independence, the Arab BLOC would use UN cease-fires as a way to rebuild their armies when the Israeli defense forces were winning. Hezbollah needs time to live in the limelight, rearm, and replenish their ranks.

The other obstacle is whether or not the new UN force can be effective in any way at disarming Hezbollah and preventing attacks from either side. At first it seemed like many western nations were offering support, now it appears some are having second thoughts. Worst yet, Hezbollah has not only said they will not disarm, but Nasrallah says he prefers working secretly with the Lebanese government for cooperation...

...why do I have a bad feeling about that?

If the UN peacekeeping force can be effecient in their task, we have nothing to worry about. Disarming won't happen in a day, maybe not even a week, but it has to happen. Hezbollah can't be allowed to control their own state-within-a-state, for both Israel and Lebanon's sake. If the UN is incompetent in their execution then the cease-fire is as worthless as the paper it's on, and events will repeat themselves. That is why this task is so important.

The grand question now is who will take up the bell?

By the way, I know some of my readers have become annoyed that I talk about the Middle East a lot. I apologize, it's just a favorite subject of mine.