Showing posts with label Tom Toles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tom Toles. Show all posts

Sunday, April 02, 2006

What's satire and what's just wrong?

I guess its a good start, considering the controversy over the Danish cartoons, to show off a political cartoon I did two years back in response to the controversy over a comic done by Ted Rall. Ted Rall, who is so far left he fell off the political scale, did a comic about the death of Pat Tillman, who as you may remember was the pro-football player who gave up his job to join the army. Ted Rall portrayed him as racist (in the comic he asks the recruiter, "Will I get to kill Arabs?") and at the end of the comic flat-out calls him an "idiot." There was a big uproar and it was removed from the MSNBC website where his cartoons are normally posted. So that you can decide for yourself while I blog, here's a link to his original comic.

With the Danish cartoons there's a whole debate over what's offensive and what's free speech. I do sometimes I disagree with political cartoonists, professionals and amatuers, but I've never hated them or felt angry directly at them. Say, for example, this Tom Toles cartoon. I may disagree with it or what he's trying to say, but if I met him face-to-face I'd still be a gentleman - I respect his right for an opinion and I believe he got it across well. Besides, he's not making a direct attack at Bush as a person or supporters of the administration, he's criticizing what he personally believes was a shoddy presidency. Ted Rall, on the other hand, was making a personal attack at Pat Tillman, a guy I'm willing to bet he never met in his life and never knew except outside the news. What's funny is that Ted Rall has done this before and whenever people get mad he claims no one can make a good argument against his beliefs. Well of course no one can - that's like calling someone's mother a whore and wondering why they get so mad.

With the Danish cartoons it's something of a mixed bag. I can understand why Muslims would get mad at cartoons like the Mohammed with a bomb for a turban - I know what the artist is getting at, but I can also understand why this offends people. I gotta admit though, some of those cartoons are pretty funny. The one with the guy saying, "Stop! Stop! We've run out of virgins!" made me laugh, and the one with the women in burkhas and the man with his eyes crossed out is a biting satire at conservative Muslim culture. The ironic thing to me is how some people reacted to this: someone calls you a terrorist and suggests your culture is ready to explode...so you burn embassies down.

Er...what?

Granted, I know this wasn't every Muslim's reaction, but those things only go to prove the other person right. If I had gone over to Ted Rall's house and beaten him up I would have just been playing into the hands of far left-wingers who think all supporters of the war are rednecks and inherently violent and oppressive. Confucious once said, "Treat good with good; treat evil with justice."

So in regards to political cartoons, I do think there's a line between what's acceptable and what's not. Just because one necessarily disagrees with a comic does not negate its role as satire.