Showing posts with label Nazi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nazi. Show all posts

Sunday, April 16, 2006

On censorship and "hyphenated Americans"

Here's an interesting image. What you are seeing are two versions of a comic I did for The District. The comic was done in response to a kid's bike getting stolen by a homeless guy who had somehow gotten past security. My goal was ultimately just to mock the incompetant security guards who seem to man our walls, as well as pick on any organization - school or company - who chooses guards based on need rather than merit. The comics editor said he was worried about people being offended by my portrayal of the African-American guard, so I erased the lines and put on some glasses and reworded what he was saying. Instantly, it was much "better."

I'm not going to go on a rant about The District. I hate it when artists attack their employers over trivial matters, and besides I appreciate them for letting me work at all. (not to mention for being very lenient in regards to deadlines and fixing my mistakes) What just amuses me is how wrong my point was taken. I wasn't trying to plaster a caricature in the paper and say, "Behold! This is how what all black people are like!" I made him talk like that because - guess what? - that's how our guards talked. I've always believed the worse stereotype is from people who stereotype themselves. If black Americans don't want to be portrayed in a "Yo yo fo' Biggie" kind of atmosphere, then don't act like that in such a way that makes people laugh. It's not that slang is bad or that it's not good to speak the way you want to, but there's a reason white people aren't walking around talking like some yuppie at a golf club. To put it another way, I read a review of "Half Past Dead" that compared Jah Rule to other rappers: you see, there are some rappers like Fifty Cent who have grown up in the ghetto and know what life on the street is, and then there are rappers like Jah Rule who like to pretend they do so they can fit into the whole rap schibang. Let me put it in another perspective: being white and acting "black" to be cool (like posers do - geez do I hate those guys) is just the same as being black and acting "black" to be cool.

On another note, I was watching the film "The Pianist" a few weeks ago. Excellent film, and seeing a re-enactment of the Holocaust got me thinking to all these people who compare Republicans to Nazis in their belief regarding homosexuals. I thought, "Look, it's not like we're putting them in ghettos and making them wear something to single them out from everyone else...oh wait." I realized that that was what was happening - but it wasn't the government doing it, it was the people themselves. In a quest for individuality and unity among their own, the different minority groups had inadvertingly done to themselves what the Nazis did to the Jews in the early 1930's. They had allowed themselves to be separated and had further worstened it by singling themselves out. Granted, part of this was historical, with poor minorities crowding into the poorer sections of cities, and segregation had some part in it, but it seems to have grown worse. What does it mean when Kanye West can say on TV "My people are suffering in New Orleans" and not mean all the Americans? What does it mean when homosexuals wear their orientation on their sleeve? And what does it mean when any group has to live as a stereotype and not as an individual?

The thing that shocked the world in the 1930's and made what was happening to the Jews so repugnant was that before they were an accepted part in our society. Hitler himself admitted that he saw Jews everywhere, even places he would never expect them. By separating them and labeling them they dehumanized the Jews - they were no longer Germans. Theodore Roosevelt long ago warned against "hyphenated Americans" and was worried if America did not assimilate the way she was supposed to we would become nothing more than a "tangle of squabbling nationalities." It's OK to be black, gay, of Mexican descent, or whatever! Let's cut all the rubbish and remember we are all Americans, first and foremost.

Saturday, April 08, 2006

"A man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest"

This comic was inspired by an incident in which someone made a case that Israel had bad human rights. In trying to prove their case, they used a lot of sources that were blatantly anti-Israel and therefore had a clear bias. When this was brought up a lot of people said, "Hey, good enough for me. I don't like Israel any way." Another example could be the fame of Michael Moore, and the response of his fans that even if he spins the truth or doesn't present things the way they are, he nonetheless "makes a good point."

Voltaire once said, "When we hear news we should await the sacrament of confirmation." There's another saying that goes, "Believe half of what you see and none of what you hear." These days it appears the new motto is, "Believe anything." There is a big habit among people to believe anything they hear, either because they want to believe it or because they're just plain gullible. I overheard some people who had heard about these dolphins trained by the government to hunt and kill terrorists being released into the wild by Hurricane Katrina. I checked online and found that the newspaper "The Guardian" had published the story and several blogs had linked to it. Reading the blogs was hilarious - hilarious because people bought into this! I asked my father about it, since he had gone to Louisiana and investigated what happened, and he confirmed the falseness in the story. Even if I can confirm it was made-up, it's ridiculous people would readily believe this.

Another example I can think of goes back to my time on Fort Benning. There was a war college for Southern American generals there called "The School of the Americas," and every year there were protests against it. The protestors called it the "School of Assassins" and claimed we were training people to overthrow their governments or torture their people. None of this was true - in fact the protestors were invited to tour the school, and most of them turned it down. Why? Well it's better to protest and meet celebrities and get your time on TV than have "the cause" ended because you had your foot placed firmly in your mouth. Unfortunately there are people who, perusing through the ever believable internet, read so-called accounts of the school and believe to this day that it was trained as some kind of Nazi grammar school. I pointed out that from my personal experience the "cause" was false and the school was nothing more than a war college, to which a firm believer responded, "Yes, who to believe, who to believe..."

Good question. I could trust myself and people I know personally, or I could trust some guy who got his information from some random internet source. Mh...yes, who to believe indeed!

I honestly believe the internet is the death of any hope the journalism world had of recovering itself. With major news group you get scrutinized by watchdog groups, and you can have your viewers correct you or point out your faults. With the internet there's no control over the content and no standards for truth, and there doesn't seem to be a nation-wide realization that just because it's written doesn't mean it's fact. Nowadays any fool can get online and post whatever they want.

Hey wait a minute...