Showing posts with label John Kerry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Kerry. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

What, me apologize?

Charlotte Branch giving John Kerry some subtle advice. You may have noticed her in some of my other works - she's a character of mine who's a fictional reporter for "ENN." (which stands for Entertainment News Network - the entertainment being unintentional) Her attitude is loosely based off a BBC journalist who will often interview people on the radio program. While she maintains an objective stand, I've noticed she asks some head-on questions that you would never expect a normal journalist to ask. (she was the one who asked the Hezbollah official about using civilians as shields in my entry here) If you don't know who the other person is, I can't help you.

Recently there's been some criticism towards John Kerry about words he said to a college crowd. He opened up with:
You know, education, if you make the most of it, you study hard, you do your homework and you make an effort to be smart, you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq.
You can see a video of it here. (to Kerry's credit he got some laughter, albeit a rather weak, polite laughter at that) The immediate response was that this was an insult against our troops, saying soldiers serving in Iraq are inherently stupid, or that if you fail college you join the military and get sent overseas. The president has criticized him, veteran groups have criticized him, and other senators have criticized Kerry as well.

Kerry has issued a quick response, which was put up on his website. He has said he will not apologize, and blames the Bush administration for blowing a bad joke out of proportion. Despite this, people are still demanding an apology from him.

Those who know me know I'm pretty tolerant about apologies from public figures. When Bill Clinton confessed to having sex with women I could've cared less. When Mel Gibson apologized for his anti-semitic comments I shrugged my shoulders, knowing society would find a way to move on. As for John Kerry, if he came out and said, "I'm sorry for what I said," I would accept it and move on with life. As it stands, however, his current "apology" falls short of sounding like a whiny little boy. I actually think it's worse than the thing he's apologizing for!

Take this bit for example:
If anyone thinks a veteran would criticize the more than 140,000 heroes serving in Iraq and not the president who got us stuck there, they're crazy. This is the classic G.O.P. playbook. I’m sick and tired of these despicable Republican attacks that always seem to come from those who never can be found to serve in war, but love to attack those who did.
At the risk of sounding crude, this is the "Boo hoo I'm a veteran so leave me alone!" excuse that you often hear when Democrat politicians who are also military veterans are criticized in regards to war. It's the idea "I fought in a war, you didn't, so you can't say anything," as if experience in an unrelated war makes you an expert in the one we're fighting right now. I'm not lambasting Kerry's Vietnam War record - far from it - but it amuses me when people say, "He's a war veteran!" in defense of his words. Yes he's a war veteran - but not of the Iraq war. His role right now is as a politician, and if he fails at that job then he deserves to be criticized.

I might also add that it is humorous Kerry criticizes the Republican party for attacking him and says the attacks "always seem to come from those who never can be found to serve in war, but love to attack those who did." Was he referring to Republicans like John Warner, who enlisted in the navy in World War II and later the Marines in the Korean War? Was he referring to John McCain, who served in Vietnam and was captured (and tortured) by the Vietnamese - and has personally asked John Kerry to apologize for his words? Are these the "Republican hacks" who have "never worn the uniform of our country" but "lie and distort so blatantly and carelessly about those who have?"

And again, that remark is an attempt to play the "I'm a veteran, you're not" card. Could you imagine a scenario where Republican Senator John Ensign says something about animals, John Kerry criticizes him, and in response Senator Ensign says, "I was a veterinarian! You weren't! So ha!"

Kerry also sinks to a new low by name-calling and insulting some of his critics. He refers to Tony Snow as "a stuffed suit White House mouthpiece standing behind a podium." He specifically mentions Rush Limbaugh and says he will no doubt "take a break from belittling Michael J. Fox’s Parkinson’s disease to start lying about me just as they have lied about Iraq." While I did not agree with Limbaugh's criticism of Fox, targeting him and putting him in the same bag as government officials who led the way into Iraq is just childish, and his name-calling of Tony Snow is even more ridiculous. (he's the press secretary - of course he's the mouthpiece!)

One damage I've noticed this caused is it has even confused people on the left. While Kerry says he was targeting Bush, some liberals and people on the extreme left are attempting to become apologists for how Kerry's words were originally taken. Some have argued, "Some people who can't afford college go into the military!" Besides supporting the crude stereotype that American soldiers are disinterested kids wanting to pay for college, this doesn't relate at all to Kerry's remarks about education and intelligence. Some have even argued, "But...our soldiers are dumb!" It is unfortunate that Kerry apologists have disregarded that even he said, "I was referring to Bush, not soldiers" and are resorting to a highschool mentality in a blind effort to defend their favorite party. It reminds me of right-wing people who tried to justify Abu Ghraib even after the Bush administration had come out and said it was a terrible, unjustified event. I'm not sure what is more sad: the fact people actually believe this, or the fact there are soldiers dying right now for the right to talk this way.

In all honesty, it is ironic that John Kerry accuses the Republicans of making a strawman argument when his whole response to the scandal is, in fact, a strawman argument. Instead of saying, "It was a bad joke, I'm sorry, here's what I really meant," he's saying, "I didn't mean that! Those cowardly Republicans are turning everyone against me!" He is attempting to draw the aim away from him and back from the administration, which is the wrong route to go and will only drag this out longer. Will this decide the November elections? No, I don't think so, but it will force him to retract more words and explain himself further - and as a political maxim says, "If you're explaining, you're losing."

UPDATE: Someone showed me a link to a response from a military unit in Iraq. Enjoy