Showing posts with label Ted Rall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ted Rall. Show all posts

Monday, November 20, 2006

Silence Him

Saddam Hussein was sentenced to death. As usual, he tried to make a show of it. Actually he did, although contrary to what Ted Rall tried to make of it, he was hardly the esteemed statesman.

Whenever the Iraq War comes up, I always tell people I was for it going in, and I am still supportive of it now. I never concerned myself with the weapons of mass destruction, my main concern was Saddam Hussein himself. Whether or not anti-war people will admit it, he was a horrible man, he did nothing constructive for the region, and I do believe the Middle East is better off without him.

It is true there are other terrible dictatorships out there, yet I don't believe any were more horrible than Saddam Hussein's regime. The mass starvation in North Korea is more a result of terrible government policy. Robert Mugabe's government will arrest or beat up political opponents, but you don't have mass graves and few people seem to be actually targeted and killed. Iran and Belarus will target political enemies, and many will disappear, and while that is terrible it pales in comparison to what happened under Saddam's regime.

A good book to look into this is the Iraqi Perspectives Project, an account of the Iraq invasion from the Iraqi point of view. It was completed by the United States Joint Forces Command (USJFCOM) with sources from Iraqi documents and interviews with Iraqi officials. A version of it open to the public can be found here for people to read. My father worked on it, thus I happily own a personal copy I will be quoting from.

It annoys me when people try to compare Bush to Saddam Hussein, or say they're both equally evil. Remember when Colin Powell and George W. Bush had their differences? What became of that? Colin Powell resigned and is now living comfortably. What would it be like under Saddam Hussein? An excerpt from JFCOM's report gives a small taste of what happened in Iraq's alternate universe:
A 1982 incident gives a small taste of what the next two decades of Saddam's tyranny would entail. At one low point in the Iran-Iraq War, Saddam asked his ministers for candid advice on what to do. With some temerity the Minister of Health suggested that Saddam temporarily step down but resume the presidency after the establishment of peace. Saddam had him carted away immediately. The next day chopped-up pieces of the minister's body were delivered to his wife. (pg 7)
Saddam would continue to rule like this, even after the first Gulf War. Even suggesting the invasion of Kuwait had been a mistake was dangerous, as "the dictator's response to such impertinence was likely to be fatal." (pg 13) His son Qusay would often invoke his father's name to strike fear into government officials and get them to follow his orders, similar to the use of "Fuehrer's princple" in Nazi Germany.

Saddam was also a source of anxiety for the entire region. He openly funded terrorist groups within Palestine, and offered money to the parents of those who martyred themselves. During Operation Desert Storm he fired missiles at Israel because he thought there was a great Jewish conspiracy against him. He held bizarre believes such as that "Iraq's difficulties with the United Nations were exacerbated by the fact that Butros-Butros Ghali had a mother who was Jewish and...had married a Jewess." (pg 5) Saddam even believed that the Mongols of the Middle Ages had turned from the west to sack Baghdad because of a great Jewish conspiracy. For a short while in the mid-1990's there was even a scheme to attack Kuwait again, and it was only through the growth of US troops in the region that the plans were diverted.

Yet one cannot discuss Saddam without mentioning the atrocities committed under his regime. There were the crimes against the Kurds during the revolt - civilian and rebel alike - and the gassing of the marshland Arabs, followed by the draining of the marshland. (this only ended after the 2003 invasion) Many people say, "If the Iraqi people didn't like Saddam Hussein, they would have overthrown him." The fact is many - including the Kurds and Shi'ites - did try, and all attempts failed. Saddam met each threat harshly, killing innocent civilians in an attempt squash the will of the people. Imagine if the American Civil War had ended not with the South being forgiven and welcomed back into the Union, but with leaders executed and southern families butchered like animals. Saddam's regime had little mercy for its enemies or friends, and it did not differentiate from the guilty and the innocent.

A recorded meeting between Hussein and his generals showed the amount of willingness he had in regards to killing civilians. In it, he details how to handle the victory over Kuwait:
Saddam: We will divide the [Iraqi] tribes into groups. Each group will be assigned to liberate a certain area of Kuwait and allowed to take any spoils they find there.
Minister: What kind of spoils?
Saddam: Spoils like buildings and stones. Also the chief of the tribe will take full control of the area his tribe has liberated - though the chief and tribe must obey my orders without arguing. I ask the security services to kill any rebellious individuals they find, their children as well.
Minister: Your Excellency, what if we find that some of the rebellious ones have little brothers and sisters that may one day avenge them?
Saddam: Kill them all. (pg 4)
The question is, of course, was it necessary to dethrone him, and was it for the better? I recently read a good article in the Jerusalem Post about this, and it struck close to me. It seemed to be putting into coherent words ideas which I believed but could not put together in a connected argument. The writer makes an excellent point about the decision to go in, as well about the fickleness of society in regards to dictators and wars.
To say, as [Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert] did, that the American campaign in Iraq has had "a dramatic and positive effect on security and stability in the Middle East" is to say something so patently absurd...The only case that remains to be made on its behalf is that it was worth doing anyway...

...The argument would go something like this: The decision to invade Iraq and topple the regime of Saddam Hussein was, under the circumstances in which it was made, a sensible calculated risk. Contrary to subsequent accusations, the president and his advisers had no certain way of knowing that Saddam Hussein did not possess, or was not in the process of developing, weapons of mass destruction. On the contrary, Saddam's repeated stonewalling of all international efforts at inspection was strong prima facie evidence that he did have and was developing such weapons...

Yet...the tyranny of his rule, and his repeated flouting of the international community, fully justified his forcible removal. If he was not a menace to the world, he was still one to his own people. It is ironic that the same critics who now castigate America for going into Iraq castigated it for decades before that for tolerating far less brutal dictatorships than Saddam's that were its allies in the Cold War. One cannot without a great deal of hypocrisy blame the United States both for supporting dictatorships and for overthrowing the worst of them.

Moreover, the hope of accompanying this overthrow with the creation of a genuine Iraqi democracy, the first of its kind in the Arab world, was not only a noble one, it was...a perfectly logical strategy to pursue. There was clearly an interconnection between Muslim fundamentalism, the economic and social backwardness of Arab countries, the jihadist ideology of Islamic terror, and the lack of democracy in the Arab world, and the notion that breaking this nexus in one major Arab country might start a chain reaction was not unreasonable.

...No one had ever previously tried to make a democratic Iraq; how could anyone know in advance that it couldn't be done? One could just as well have argued in 1945 that Japan, a country with an Oriental mentality, an authoritarian social structure, and no democratic traditions to speak of, could not possibly be democratized, either.

Indeed, suppose for a moment that America had invaded Iraq...and installed one of his ex-henchmen in his place, a cooperative generalissimo willing to play ball with Washington in return for a free hand in continuing the repression in Baghdad - what would today's critics of the war in Iraq have said then? It's easy enough to imagine: "There go those Americans again, championing democracy in theory and trampling in practice! Who says the Iraqis aren't ready for democracy? What a condescendingly racist notion it is to think that some people aren't capable of knowing what's good for them simply because they're Arabs!"

In short, George W. Bush was faced, in early 2003, with three possibilities. He could have decided against military action, let Saddam stay in power, and been blamed for it; he could have ousted Saddam, replaced him with a Saddam-lite, and been blamed for that too; or he could have done what he has done - and faced being blamed for that also. In the end, he chose the best of the three alternatives. It didn't work out as he had hoped? No, it didn't. There is always a chance that things won't work out. That's not always a sufficient reason to do nothing.

Saddam has recently been sentenced to hang by the neck until dead, and I believe this is a fitting end for one of history's worst dictators. He will not die the easy way - through suicide like Hitler - he will not die of natural causes - like Stalin did - and he will not die never being fully brought to justice - like Milosevic did. He has been found guilty of his crimes, and he will be punished for it - and, ironically, by his own people. One of the strongest things that showed this change in Iraq from Saddam's tryanny towards a more democratic government came during the trial when this exchange happened between Saddam and Judge Rahman:

Saddam: I led you for 35 years and now you order me out of the court?
Rahman: I am the judge, you are the defendant. You have to obey me.

Sunday, April 02, 2006

What's satire and what's just wrong?

I guess its a good start, considering the controversy over the Danish cartoons, to show off a political cartoon I did two years back in response to the controversy over a comic done by Ted Rall. Ted Rall, who is so far left he fell off the political scale, did a comic about the death of Pat Tillman, who as you may remember was the pro-football player who gave up his job to join the army. Ted Rall portrayed him as racist (in the comic he asks the recruiter, "Will I get to kill Arabs?") and at the end of the comic flat-out calls him an "idiot." There was a big uproar and it was removed from the MSNBC website where his cartoons are normally posted. So that you can decide for yourself while I blog, here's a link to his original comic.

With the Danish cartoons there's a whole debate over what's offensive and what's free speech. I do sometimes I disagree with political cartoonists, professionals and amatuers, but I've never hated them or felt angry directly at them. Say, for example, this Tom Toles cartoon. I may disagree with it or what he's trying to say, but if I met him face-to-face I'd still be a gentleman - I respect his right for an opinion and I believe he got it across well. Besides, he's not making a direct attack at Bush as a person or supporters of the administration, he's criticizing what he personally believes was a shoddy presidency. Ted Rall, on the other hand, was making a personal attack at Pat Tillman, a guy I'm willing to bet he never met in his life and never knew except outside the news. What's funny is that Ted Rall has done this before and whenever people get mad he claims no one can make a good argument against his beliefs. Well of course no one can - that's like calling someone's mother a whore and wondering why they get so mad.

With the Danish cartoons it's something of a mixed bag. I can understand why Muslims would get mad at cartoons like the Mohammed with a bomb for a turban - I know what the artist is getting at, but I can also understand why this offends people. I gotta admit though, some of those cartoons are pretty funny. The one with the guy saying, "Stop! Stop! We've run out of virgins!" made me laugh, and the one with the women in burkhas and the man with his eyes crossed out is a biting satire at conservative Muslim culture. The ironic thing to me is how some people reacted to this: someone calls you a terrorist and suggests your culture is ready to explode...so you burn embassies down.

Er...what?

Granted, I know this wasn't every Muslim's reaction, but those things only go to prove the other person right. If I had gone over to Ted Rall's house and beaten him up I would have just been playing into the hands of far left-wingers who think all supporters of the war are rednecks and inherently violent and oppressive. Confucious once said, "Treat good with good; treat evil with justice."

So in regards to political cartoons, I do think there's a line between what's acceptable and what's not. Just because one necessarily disagrees with a comic does not negate its role as satire.