Showing posts with label Fatah. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fatah. Show all posts

Monday, June 18, 2007

Oh, this makes things easier...

Well, this has been quite an active time for Palestine, hasn't it?

Within a week, Hamas forces in the Gaza Strip launched an assault against Fatah, overrunning their positions and effectively becoming the rulers of the territory. (even stealing Yasser Arafat's Nobel peace prize) Fatah, in turn, launched attacks against Hamas positions in the West Bank. Over 160 Palestinians were killed and 796 wounded during the fighting. (half of them reported to be Fatah activists and Palestinian Authority security personnel) What had been building up since the 2006 elections now reached a hilt. At one point, the West Bank and Gaza Strip were separated because of Israel denying or limiting access between them. Now, with Hamas in control of the Gaza Strip and Fatah the de facto rulers of the West Bank, that separation is political.

The international community's influence in the region changed practically overnight. The United States and EU announced they would normalize relations with the Palestinian Authority, and have supported President Mahmoud Abbas' dismissal of the Hamas-majority government.

Israel, for her part, has been very reasonable. They will continue to allow water into the West bank, an Israeli official even saying the Palestinian people are "not going to be punished for what is going on there." Although Israel has limited the influx of refugees, they have allowed many people to enter, and in one instance the IDF even gave medical attention to Palestinians caught in a crossfire. An Israeli oil supplier also renewed its flow into the Strip, and on Monday Israel allowed medical supplies across the border. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert announced that Israel would release tax revenues withheld while Hamas was in power (amounting to $700 million) and pledged to cooperate with the new government.

A third wheel, one overlooked by much of the American media, is Egypt. Egypt has been a player in the Gaza Strip since the violence between Hamas and Fatah began to increase the refugee problem and Israel began to pressure the Egyptian government to stem the flow of weapons. Hamas is also an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, a movement that has considerable influence within Egypt. Egypt is therefore stuck in the middle between Fatah and Hamas as much as Israel is, and will have to be very careful in her handling of this issue. As it currently stands, Egypt is cutting off the route of refugees and continuing to play mediator between the two Palestinian power groups.

The way I see it, a few routes can come from this:
  • Hamas is isolated in the Gaza Strip, and treated by Israel as an entity they can finally deal with on plain terms. No longer is Hamas a force in all of Palestine, now - like Hezbollah or the Taliban - they have a designated sphere of control. This can either lead to the annihilation of Hamas in the Palestinian territories or the isolation of their violence. If they are pushed out, they would most likely flee to Lebanon, where some elements are supposedly already present. Chances are this will not happen any time soon, as the Israeli government has said that (at least for now) they will not intercede in the Palestinian civil conflict. If the Quartet and Israel can put enough pressure on Egypt, however, and an increased effort by the Quartet to limit the influence of Iran is made, there might be some success in this.
  • A sort of "grand experiment" can now be committed, with Fatah on the West Bank being supported by the west and Middle East, and Hamas being isolated in the Gaza Strip and being forced to commit to the demands of the Quartet. (recognition of Israel, denunciation of violence, and following past and present Israeli-Palestinian agreements) The success of Abbas and his moderates could lead to an easier time agreeing to borders with Israel, and bringing Hamas into line when they feel international pressure. The problem here is that support for Fatah failed before, as Fatah is seen by any as corrupt besides inefficient. Likewise, Hamas failed to commit to the promises they made during the election, and spent most of their time fighting to gain control of Palestine. No pressure from the international community, diplomatic or economic, changed their minds. They undoubtedly will try to use this as an opportunity to incite further violence against Israel, or try to gain support among the population to go to war with Israel.
  • The two parts of the Palestinian state become entirely separate entities. The West Bank becomes a democracy, while the Gaza Strip becomes an Islamist state in the vein of Taliban-run Afghanistan. They have already threatened political enemies with death, and there have been accounts of gang-style executions of Fatah members by Hamas gunmen. There has also been an increase in Christian persecution, which Hamas has denied any connection to but which also happened under their watch in the Hamas sections of the West Bank. In the wake of international pressure and a possibly dissident population, Hamas may seek to strengthen her control over the Strip. This will unfortunately involve religion.
No doubt we shall soon see how this will play out. Hamas may find this a phyrric victory, as they will now have to deal with "a hostile international community, tension with Egypt, internal ideological divisions and provision of services to Gaza's civilian population." While Fatah running the West Bank may not be a perfect situation, a government Israel can and will work with will allow the Middle East process to continue. (limited in scope it may be)

No doubt times will become tougher for average Palestinians in the coming days. Already tired by wars between terrorist groups and Israel, they are now stuck in a civil war between Fatah and Hamas. However, thinking long-term, this could prove to either be the best or the worst thing to happen to them. It could force a stable Palestinian leadership to emerge, if not from Fatah then from the weaker, moderate parties seeking a renewed hope for peace. It could also signal, as I said before, an end to Hamas and militant groups in general.

Frankly, I could sit here and blabber on all day about what could be, but only time will tell.

Wednesday, October 25, 2006

Be thankful - no I'm serious

I don't want to sound cliche, but...Americans really are spoiled. We have so much to be thankful for, yet we find so much to complain about. And no, I'm not trying to claim infallibility - I too am guilty of doing this.

A few months ago I was doing research on Zimbabwe and how much Robert Mugabe has sent that nation into economic turmoil. It's humbling to read about starvation, poverty, and lack of energy, and then head out and everywhere in America you see food, working electricity, and plenty of gasoline. (even if people complain about prices, at least it's still there when you wake up) We're also thankful to have competent leadership. I don't care what any Democrat says - I would rather have a congress full of George W. Bush clones than have Robert Mugabe as my president.

You look at tyrannical governments like the one in Belarus and you're thankful for the little things we take for granted. Coming up are the November elections, something everyone will be able to participate in freely, and if you don't like the results you're allowed to protest. Byelorussians, meanwhile, are locked away for disliking the government, and if you protest you can disappear without a trace. Heck, even semi-democracies like Russia have problems, where more reporters have been killed than any other nation. Charles Gibson is lucky that he can go to home without a government/mafia hired killer shooting him in the head for what he said about the war in Iraq. (by the way, I have nothing against Charles Gibson, I just used him as an example)

Generally, we can all live in peace, with our only fear being crime. When my dad told me about the mass graves he found while serving in Bosnia, I was thankful that I could walk down the street and not be shot at because of my religion or ethnicity. When you hear about the condition in Darfur, spiraling out of control as we speak, you have to be thankful that no ethnic group in America is trying to drive out the other by force. Maybe people don't like that illegal Americans are being arrested and shipped back home, but at least the American military isn't bombing migrant camps.

Recently I've been following the conflict going on in Palestine right now. Armed groups loyal to either Fatah or Hamas have been combating one another for some time now. Their battles are sporadic and could hardly be called huge clashes, but nonetheless they cause more tension. Foreign Arab nations - including Egypt and Qatar - have attempted to get both sides to come to an agreement, but neither side has given ground. Hamas still refuses to acknowledge Israel's right to exist and refuses to recognize any previous agreements signed with Israel, (including those that allow Palestine to exist) while Fatah wants to go ahead with plans to cooperate with Israel and is growing tired of Hamas trying to undermine their authority, especially in the Gaza Strip. Many analysts are already saying a civil war between the two sides is imminent.

As I read these stories about the crisis in Palestine, I can't help but think about our own nation. What if the the Republicans and Democrats took up arms? What if they started to fight a war of weapons rather than with words? That is another thing we can be thankful for - the fact our political system is one of the most stable in the world. I may complain about the attack ads on TV right now, especially those between Senator George Allen and opponent Jim Webb, but at least the Allen and Webb supporters aren't firing rockets at each other. I don't hear any stories about Jim Webb's campaign manager being killed by Allen's militia men. (and no, I don't have anything against Jim Webb's campaign manager either) This is probably why it is a good thing political parties are not armed, because these things would invariably happen. Our military is thankfully nonpartisan, and will function no matter who is put in charge come this election. When Hamas took control of the Palestinian parliament, the Fatah controlled armed forces scoffed at any attempt for Hamas to give them orders. Imagine if a Democrat took control of the presidency and the military refused to cooperate.

America has some problems that we need to deal with, but everyday I have a lot to be thankful for. I just wish a lot of fellow Americans would realize this as well. If you feel bad about your nation, and you want something to make you realize how lucky you are, just start reading international news. Trust me, it'll cheer you up in a jiffy.

Thursday, July 13, 2006

That's not too assuring


A reference to the current conflict in the Middle East, with Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniya offering some assurances to an Israeli soldier.

There's been a lot of discussion about this, and a lot of people seem to want to put the blame on Israel. ABC Nightly News (which, quite frankly, does a piss-poor job of reporting the Middle East conflict) makes it seem like this is the first time any conflict across the border has occurred. Other people make it sound like Israel just up and decided to invade random areas. This is hardly the truth. I personally believe the current situation is more a failure of diplomacy over the past few months, and much of the blame is upon our ol' friends Hamas.

Since November, Hamas have been asked to modify their charter and at least accept Israel's right to exist. Besides Israeli pressure, they have been told to by "the Quartet" (EU, UN, America, Russia) as well as Arab neighbors. (including Egypt, Jordan, and Turkey) Since then Hamas has done very little and made nearly no progress. While Israel waited patiently for Hamas to reform and was going ahead to finalize borders between Israel and Palestine (as well as pull out of Palestinian territory unilaterally) Hamas continued to attack Israel's infrastructure. There was the terrorist attack months ago in an Israeli city, and there have been continued rocket attacks from the West Bank. Meanwhile Hamas never accepted Israel's right to exist and would not even accept past peace treaties with Israel - treaties, mind you, that allowed the Palestinian Authority's existance. While there was a move by some individuals in Hamas to set a more moderate tone for the organization to allow negotiations with Israel to continue, they made little headway.

Hamas continued to act oblivious to any kind of diplomatic responsibility. The Israeli army has reportedly stopped over 100 terrorist attacks from Gaza in the past several months. When the terrorist attack from a few months ago occurred Prime Minister Haniya made a weak response for it, nearly giving the "they deserved it" excuse. While I understand that Haniya himself doesn't have the control of the militant wing of Hamas, the organization in its entirety needs to realize that they are being watched and that their actions have consequences - you can't make weak promises with one wing and then break them all with the other wing.

The kidnapping of the Israeli soldier is no doubt the straw that broke the camel's back. Israel has had enough of waiting for Hamas to reform and must take action to defend her people from an enemy who wishes for the destruction of the Jewish people. It is the same for Hezbollah, who I think made an incredibly dumb move: they planned the operation months in advance, (or so they say) and they really believed that Israel would negotiate - all this AFTER Israel's response to Hamas' similar action. Now Israel is involved in Lebanon and Gaza, fighting two terrorist organizations on two fronts. ABC Nightly News made this sound like a major deal, but considering this is the same nation that took three enemies on three fronts in a war and won it in six days, I'm not very worried.

The Palestinian Authority for the longest time needed a reliable government. They could not have it under Yasser Arafat, and they were getting it under Mahmoud Abbas. Hamas has set Palestine back several years, going back to the Arafat days of promising a ceasefire then planning more terrorist attacks. If Hamas wants the world to respect them as a political party they need to realize that there is no longer room for fanatical terrorism. The majority of Palestinians support a two-state agreement, Israel is willing to withdraw unilaterally, most Israelis want to leave Palestine alone...this is the ideal situation the Middle East has been waiting for, and something Hamas should realize they need to participate with. If they are not a terrorist group then they should distance themselves away from terrorism, denounce terrorist acts, and change their beliefs so that Israel has a right to exist and all treaties with her are respected. Instead of saying something like, "I promise the hostage won't get killed" try to get the soldier freed. Denounce terrorism. If you embrace this kind of racist fanaticism then you will only be more disrespected by the international community.

I'm hoping that this is not a long, drawn-out crisis that lasts longer than expected. And I still have some high hopes for the Israeli-Palestinian situation despite this. Hey, I'm an optimist.

Friday, May 12, 2006

Give peace at least five minutes

I'm pretty proud of how this came out. I doodled this in my sketchbook in a few minutes using a fancy ink pen and reference photos of Abbas and Olmert. If you don't know what the rat is supposed to represent, you haven't been following news from the Middle East.

My subject for Contemporary Issues class is "Should America Become More Involved in Israel?" And by involved I don't mean sending troops to the West Bank, I mean on the diplomatic level. I am very pro-involvement, because America is seen high on the list of "respected opinions" among the "Quartet" powers that often moderates what goes on in the Middle East. During my research I went to the Palestinian government's website and found that under relations they said they loved America - in fact, they blamed any problems with America on Israel.

With the recent election of Hamas in the Palestinian parliament, the hopes for peace seem to have run into some bumpy roads. How is Abbas supposed to help negotiate concrete peace with Israel when a large portion of his government doesn't even respect Israel's right to exist? I found a copy of Hamas' charter, and it is some scary stuff. They sincerely believe Jews, freemasons, and other secret organizations started World War II, control the UN, and helped prop up Israel. This is the typical "Jews control the world" conspiracy that got old with Hitler. People sometimes say hating Israel isn't being anti-semitic - well, I think in this case we can safely assume it is.

The recent action of removing aide and then returning it brings up another interesting issue - how can the international community deal with Hamas? While we were trying to convince Middle Eastern nations that democracy helps prevent fanatics from attaining power, fanatics did so in Palestine. Pressure can come - with nations like Egypt or Saudi Arabia shaking their heads - to do something to show that the world will not tolerate terrorist organizations getting power like this. Hamas turned a deaf ear to the international community's plea to change the harsher parts of their charter. Rightfully they should have: their charter disrupts not only the Oslo treaty signed back in the early 1990's but disrupts the fundamentals of the Roadmap for Peace. With Israel willing to continue the sacrifices started by Sharon and wanting to continue negotiations for permanent borders, the last thing you need is a Palestinian government that will just shrug its shoulders at terrorist attacks and accept no responsibility.

The problem is that removing funds could have had disastrous consequences for Palestine. Businesses were losing money, medical institutions were suffering, and it was predicted the infrastructure would collapse sooner than originally expected. On the up side, we're punishing Hamas and pressuring them to change their ways; on the down side, we're harming the Palestinian people. Many critics say this would do nothing to turn the people against Hamas, who would most likely use Israel as a scapegoat. The other dangerous aspect is the presence of Iran in the region. Iran has already had a history funding Hezbollah and Hamas in its own indirect war on Israel. With their nuclear plans threatened, Iran sought to gain support in the region by saying it would send Hamas the necessary funds. Many other nations, including Kuwait, pledged donations as well. Banks were ultimately hesitant of cooperating for fear of backlash from international powers, including the United States.

Now the Quartet have gone through with proposed plans to go around Hamas and fund the Palestinian people directly. In many ways, I'm happy with this response - the Palestinian people receive help and Hamas is not given the honor of saving their people from debt. At the same time, we prevent Iran from strengthening it's presence in the region.

The question is, what is in store for the conflict? Well, that's hard to say. Many analysts believe that Hamas will not go on an all-out war just yet - instead, they will bide their time and strengthen their power inside Palestine. There is also, I notice, a growing sentiment towards security and peace within Palestine. Many younger Palestinians are calling for a more effecient and reliable government - reliable not just in the eyes of the Palestinian people, but in the eyes of the international community.

Many are also tired of the violence: the BBC had an article about Israel's counterattacks against terrorist rocket attacks, and interviewed a young man who had lost his leg. His anger was not at Israel but at the terrorists. He wonders what good these rocket attacks do when all that happens is in the end is more Palestinians are hurt. One of the strongest arguments I read came from a father whose son joined a terrorism organization and killed himself in a suicide attack. The father asked why it was the Palestinian people, and not the terrorist leaders, who had to sacrifice their sons. This sense of leaning towards peace seems to be prevailant amongst many of the younger generations in troubled areas - in Bosnia, one can see it among the younger Serbs, Muslims and Croats who saw the civil war as nothing but senseless bloodshed.

I do not support terrorism and I dislike Hamas, but I hold no grudge against the Palestinian people. I hope they do get a government that realizes now is the best time to come to peace with Israel and accept peace in sincerity, not in hopes of collecting themselves for another intifada. Oh well. Like I said, only time will tell.