Showing posts with label IAEA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IAEA. Show all posts

Saturday, September 16, 2006

IAEA-O

A letter between International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) officials leaked out, and in it was criticism of a Congressional report from the House Intelligence Committee. (which, remember, is made up of both Democrats and Republicans) What the report detailed was the threat Iran posed to global security, including a possible weapons program. The IAEA letter criticizes the report, calling its facts "erroneous" and "misleading." This story didn't get as much coverage as it probably would have, had not there been the whole debate on capitol hill about what the definition of "torture" is, and what with the e-coli scare breaking out in 20 states. (at the time of this writing, that is) I myself have only read about it from an online BBC article. Despite this, I can only imagine how it would have been covered, and you see a hint of it on the BBC article when it says a "western diplomat" called this "deja vu of the pre-Iraq war period." I personally find it odd they couldn't name this "western diplomat."

The BBC is quite helpful in that they give you links to the report from the House Intelligence Committee, and the letter from the IAEA. This gives you a chance to read each and decide for yourself what we are seeing, which I encourage everyone to do.

One of the first things that struck me was that the IAEA letter seems to pick on small points. If you read it, you can gather that the IAEA letter basically complains that the Intelligence Committee report says:
  • Iran is enriching uranium to a "weapons-grade" level, when in fact they haven't achieved this level yet.
  • Iran is "covertly" producing the element polonium-210 (which is used for satellite batteries and nuclear weapons) when in fact Iran is not supposed to be reporting polonium-210 production.
  • Certain IAEA officials were removed for reporting the truth, when in fact they were not.
Now, to some degree, this isn't that big of a deal to me. If the first and third points are incorrect, then the two sides should compare notes and come to an understanding on the real facts. However, the second part somewhat scares me. If it is true that, short-lived or not, polonium-210 can be used for satellite batteries (yeah, that's what every one wants - Ahmadinejad freely staring down on us!) and nuclear weapons, then why isn't it supposed to be reported to the IAEA? To put things in perspective, imagine if a guy snuck a gun into a club, was caught with it, and when the police were filling out a report with "the suspect snuck a weapon in" the bouncers argued, "He didn't sneak the weapon in, because we weren't supposed to check for it." It seems like an argument of words more than principles. I should also point out that the report mentions Iran confessed in 2003 to "producing small quantities of plutonium without notifying the IAEA, a violation of its treaty obligations."

What I find funny, however, is that this story seems to overshadow the real message of the report, especially some of the passages that may calm antsy IAEA inspectors. For example, right at the beginning of page 4 the report says "the US Intelligence Community believes that Tehran probably has not yet produced or acquired the fissile material (weapons-grade nuclear fuel) needed to produce a nuclear weapon." It even goes on to say that they don't expect Iran to have any nuclear weapon capabilities until the beginning of the next decade or the middle of the next decade - so it's not exactly pre-Iraq war hysteria, because we're not worried about what Iran has now, it's what they might have later. This is something important to be wary of, because as the report points out:
  • Iran has the largest inventory of ballistic missiles in the Middle East.
  • Iran openly funds terrorist groups like Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Islamic Jihad.
These are all real threats. Even more interesting, the report makes the point that a nuclear armed Iran will most likely exert greater influence in the region, believing it's nuclear arsenal will add more muscle to its words. It will especially add tensions around Israel, who, as many of you know, is not exactly Ahmadinejad's favorite country in the world. How would you feel if the world leader who said you should "be wiped off the map" suddenly got his hands on the most destructive force in the world?

One also has to wonder, if the IAEA letter covers only the wrong facts, how much the rest of the report is. I would like to know if:
  • The IAEA discovered documentation that Iran for constructing and running uranium hemispheres, which are "relevant to production of nuclear weapon components."
  • Iran really does have 85 tons of uranium hexafluoride, which if enriched to weapons-grade material will be enough for 12 nuclear bombs.
  • Dr. A.Q. Khan, the "father of Pakistan's nuclear weapons program," confessed to secretly providing nuclear technology to Iran, Libya, and North Korea just before Iran confessed to obtaining uranium centrifuge technology on the black market in 2004.
  • Iran "does not have enough indigenous uranium resources to fuel even one power-generating reactor," but has enough uranium "to make several nuclear bombs."
There are all still horrifying to discover. Especially if you look at the report's map of Iran's missile coverage and see that some of their missiles can travel as far as Germany or Finland in Europe, India in southeast Asia, and Kenya in Africa. Maybe it's not a direct threat to our homeland, but it is a definite source of anxiety for the entire region.

In the end, I'm glad this did not get wide-spread coverage, because it would have been distorted as a "Holy cow another WMD excuse!" story, rather than an attempt by the Intelligence Committee to say, "Here's where we stand. Here's what we believe. Here's what we need to know more about." The end of the documentation calls for a greater watch on Iran, not war. We need to make sure Iran doesn't have the capability to produce a nuclear weapon, and if they do then we definitely need to know about it before they can build one missile.

Of course, this should be apparent since it's the House Intelligence Committee, which is responsible for...um...uh...oh yeah! Intelligence.