Showing posts with label Crusades. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crusades. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

The crusaders are just misunderstood

What if roles were reversed, a la the movie "White Man's Burden?" (John Travolta comments aside) What if the Crusades happened now, with the Christians launching attacks against the Middle East. How would the more modern, free-thinking Middle East react? This humorous notion was one of the ideas behind this cartoon. It came along with a pet-peeve of mine, which is when people play apologists for our modern Islamists who commit terrorist acts against the West.

First, let's talk about those Crusade apologists who actually do make such arguments as the one mentioned in my cartoon. Some say that the Christians were merely retaking Christian land, or that they were defending the Byzantine Empire from aggressors. The problem with both these arguments is they do not hold up to history. Consider, for example, that the Muslims had captured Jerusalem in 638 AD, and the Crusades were not even contemplated until 1085, when the Byzantine EmperorAlexius Comnenus asked for assistance against the Seljuk Turks. If the Crusaders were liberating Jerusalem, they were over 400 years too late! One would almost think that this would then support the argument that the Crusaders were supporting the Byzantine Empire against the Turks. One must take into account the political games of Pope Urban II, who sought to unite Christendom and maintain the Church's influence. One must also look into history to discover that the Crusaders fought only a few battles against the Turks and, once they had gotten the Turkish army out of their way, immediately headed south to the Holy Lands.

The truth is these apologist excuses are just as absurd as the apologist excuses for jihading Muslims today.

Let's start with the "they blow themselves up because they're poor" excuse. As Muslim author Irshad Manji pointed out in her article "Muslim Myopia," the Muslim Council of Britain stated that the reason behind the July 7 bombings was because of economic discrimination. When the truth came out (that the July 7 bombers were actually middle-class on the whole) they quickly fell back to the other tactic, which was it was foreign policy that inspired the bombings. If you study the history of some individual terrorists in Iraq and Palestine, you find many of them came from middle-class families, and that many even had college education. I personally wonder exactly how poor Osama bin Laden was before September 11.

The other argument - that it's foreign policy creating it all - is just as absurd, even more so. I remember once hearing a radio jockey call it a "it's the victim's fault" mentality, but I think it shows an even higher level of ignorance. Some say assistance to Israel is causing the problem when in fact no direct link between policies toward Israel with Al Qaeda or other international terrorist groups can be found. Hamas, Fatah, and Hezbollah are all nationalist movements located to their specific area of interest, not pan-Islamic like Al Qaeda. Hamas and Hezbollah have no interest in conflict with America precisely because it does not serve their interest. Hassan Nasrallah, leader of Hezbollah, has stated that he's not interested in attacking any other nation except if they step into Lebanon, and even then attacks will stay in Lebanon. Hamas, Fatah, and Hezbollah all openly criticized the September 11 and July 7 terrorist attacks (although Nasrallah kept quiet about the Pentagon attacks) and Yasser Arafat, leader of Palestine, even donated blood for the 9/11 victims. If you look at the website for the Palestinian Ministry of Foreign Affairs you can find articles that congratulate President Bush for his re-election, and find many more that praise the USA as a negotiating partner. Any faults between Palestine and the America are blamed on Israel.

Some people might argue, "But Osama bin Laden mentions those as his reasons for jihad." When he does that, he's only looking for sympathy and support. As I said before, most nationalist movements try to distance themselves away from the pan-Islamic movements. When Osama bin Laden mentioned Western influence in Sudan and Palestine in a video, he was greeted with criticism from Sudan and Hamas. The message from these parties is clear: "We have nothing to do with that, nor do we ever want anything to do with it."

Irshad Manji makes two other fine points in her article. One is that jihadists contradict their war against evil foreign policy with what is happening in the world. Consider that the World Trade Center attack in 1993 happened after Iraq, but that Iraq war was nothing like the one today. Also consider that the attack on American embassies in Africa and the USS Cole happened only a few years after American troops had been sent into Bosnia to defend Muslim-Bosnians from the other ethnic groups. (and vice versa) It's also odd that Osama bin Laden name-drops Palestine so often, as George W. Bush has donated large sums of money in the hundreds of millions to the Palestinians. (donations that have garnered much criticism from more hardline conservatives) It's also questionable as to why jihadists would kidnap French reporters in Iraq, as France was staunchly against the Iraq war.

The second point Irshad Manji makes is that the jihadists seem oblivious to the actions of Muslim governments. Al Qaeda and their apologists claims they are fighting the West for killing Muslims when every day Al Qaeda operatives behead and kill fellow Muslims every day. Margaret Hassan, who ran a world-renowned relief agency in Baghdad, was killed by insurgents. In Sudan there are black Muslims being murdered by Arab Muslims. Where is the outcry against this? Why can't Al Qaeda fight this menace too?

Oh wait...in most of those situations, they are the menace.

Personally, I find it sad I should have to explain this and back it up with facts. Intentionally killing innocent people that have nothing to do with your cause should ring "murder" in a person's ear. I used this example before, and I'll use it again: if I get mad at the mayor of Norfolk for something, that doesn't give me an excuse to go into the Hampton Roads Bridge Tunnel and blow myself up. This "I don't like your foreign policy" doesn't fly, and cannot be considered a rational argument. The person who believes in it is a dangerous individual with no sense of human life.

Then again maybe I'm wrong. These people are, after all, fighting foreign invaders who are taking away their land inch by inch, and are fighting back for what they believe is a holy war, and it isn't my place to tell them right from wrong. I should just try to make them happy.

Huh? No I'm not talking about the jihadists, I'm talking about the crusaders.