This cartoon is based off the folk tale of the mice and the bell. In the story, a group of mice are plagued by a cat who is killing them off. They decide the best thing to do is to put a bell on the cat so they can hear him coming, but when it is asked who will actually put the bell on the cat no one answers. This morning I was trying to think of something that spoke about the whole situation in Lebanon, and this story immediately resurrected itself from my childhood.With the peace treaty there's a lot of debate about who won. Did Israel win? Did Hezbollah win? Israel claims victory because they damaged Hezbollah and are going through with the UN treaty, while Hezbollah is claiming victory because they're still around and Israel is leaving. Hezbollah, of course, doesn't tell people that Israel is only leaving because they're following the UN cease-fire agreement that Israel, Lebanon, and even Hezbollah agreed to. I'm not particularly aware of an hour-by-hour report of the war, but I doubt there was any Lebanese form of Rorke's Drift in this conflict.
In my personal opinion, the one thing that will determine who "won" this war is how the cease-fire is carried out. If a UN buffer zone can be made between Israel and Lebanon, and Hezbollah is disarmed or at least effectively tamed, then Israel can claim a victory. This is what they were trying to accomplish all along. Don't forget that the cease-fire also entails that Israel will have their soldiers returned. Some people claim this is a defeat for Israel because they didn't accomplish any of their goals - but the cease-fire agreement gives them all their goals. It also saves Israel from losing face in international pressure for the conflict. So all in all, if the agreement can be carried out to a good degree then it is a victory for Israel.
What if it can't? What if nothing happens? What if it all starts over again? Is that a victory of Hezbollah? No, it's not. It's a defeat for the Lebanese people, who will really be the losers here. They will again become stuck between warring factions, one not even a major part of their government. I have to also add my own opinion of the UN will be diminished if they cannot carry this out right. Let's not forget one of the reasons we had this conflict was because the UN was supposed to disarm Hezbollah and set up a buffer zone between Israel and Lebanon a long time ago.
There are two obstacles I see to carrying out peace. The most obvious is whether or not Israel or Hezbollah can keep the peace. Although this may sound one-sided, I'm not very worried about Israel. Don't forget the restraint they showed in the face of Hamas' continual attacks, and currently the Israeli army is giving ground to the Lebanese army as part of the peace transition. Hezbollah will no doubt try to do something to enrage Israel and earn more public support, though for now they may be on the low. Cease-fire in Arab/Muslim history have always been about rebuilding yourself and getting ready for the next attack. Mohammed himself used this tactic against enemies, and even in Israeli history you can see this: during the War of Independence, the Arab BLOC would use UN cease-fires as a way to rebuild their armies when the Israeli defense forces were winning. Hezbollah needs time to live in the limelight, rearm, and replenish their ranks.
The other obstacle is whether or not the new UN force can be effective in any way at disarming Hezbollah and preventing attacks from either side. At first it seemed like many western nations were offering support, now it appears some are having second thoughts. Worst yet, Hezbollah has not only said they will not disarm, but Nasrallah says he prefers working secretly with the Lebanese government for cooperation...
...why do I have a bad feeling about that?
If the UN peacekeeping force can be effecient in their task, we have nothing to worry about. Disarming won't happen in a day, maybe not even a week, but it has to happen. Hezbollah can't be allowed to control their own state-within-a-state, for both Israel and Lebanon's sake. If the UN is incompetent in their execution then the cease-fire is as worthless as the paper it's on, and events will repeat themselves. That is why this task is so important.
The grand question now is who will take up the bell?
By the way, I know some of my readers have become annoyed that I talk about the Middle East a lot. I apologize, it's just a favorite subject of mine.
