Showing posts with label casualties. Show all posts
Showing posts with label casualties. Show all posts

Sunday, January 21, 2007

When names become numbers

I was driving to work two days ago when I passed by a newspaper stand for the Virginia Pilot. I saw, splattered in big bold letters in big bold letters, "3,000." I nearly stopped my car. I felt my blood boil. I wanted to run the stand over, regardless of any damage suffered to the front end. Had it finally happened? Had 3,000 American service men and women died in Iraq? And had the Virginia Pilot chosen to sum up these 3,000 lives - men, women, children, mothers and fathers, brothers and sisters - as a single number on their front page?

This is something the media in general has been doing since the start of the War on Terror. A constant update on casualties in all theaters. It was like an update on your weather, and seemed to be treated with as much emotion. I remember watching a report on a soldier lost in Iraq due to an accident, and at the end the journalist read the update on how many had been killed...and I swear to God, there was a hint of a smile on her face, as if she was reading off the temperature for the day. I very nearly threw my drawing pencil at the TV. Wait...actually, I did.

The thing of it is, it didn't bother me nearly as much until my father was serving in Afghanistan, and the media began to do the same thing for that war. I read an article about a helicopter crash in Afghanistan, and sure enough at the end of the article the total number of American dead was counted off. I realized then that if my father were to die, he would not be reported as the father of three children, devoted husband, officer in an American division, or perhaps even mentioned by name. He would become, "...that makes 100+ Americans who have died in Afghanistan." Nearly 50 years of life summed into a number, and written casually in a newspaper without another thought.

Now granted, you might argue if there is another way to do this. You might also ask me if the media should just hide the total casualties. I don't agree necessarily with that idea. However, this kind of macabre score chart - reading off the total deaths every time a soldier dies (regardless of it being a battle casualty or an accident) - makes one wonder if there is any sense of tact within news producers.

And this is not confined to the Iraq or Afghanistan War - in fact, this is true for any event where a large number of people are killed. The tsunami in southeast Asia, Hurricane Katrina, the brush fires in the west coast...the numbers of people lost loses any meaning. We all grief when we hear 6,000,000 Jews were slaughtered in the Holocaust because we realize that's a staggering amount of innocent people lost for no reason. Here, some of that is lost. It becomes a number with no meaning, something updated every day. It's not meant to inform the public, it's meant to impress. And by "impress" I mean "impress" in the most darkest sense.

Think of this: what difference is there, in terms of meaning, between 2499 soldiers dying in Iraq and 2500? What makes that 2500th any different than the last? I'm not saying the 2500th soldier to die wasn't worth remembering, but what makes that number itself a "milestone?" It's not. It's a number. And it's a number used by the media to make people say, "Wow! 2500? That's a round number! This is terrible!" 2499 soldiers dying is just as bad as 2500. The only difference is that one has more zeroes and therefore looks better on a news graphic. No one remembers who that 2500th soldier to die is, or what family they had or what they did as kids, or what their unit remembers them for.

I do not believe in a liberal or conservative conspiracy within the media, so it cannot be an attempt to undermine the Bush administration. I can only think of two possible reasons for this:
  1. It is the usual sensationalist journalism that we have seen develop so much over the years, with death and destruction selling, and producers believe more people will get to the news if they hear impressive numbers - regardless of what those numbers involve.
  2. The majority of news producers and journalists failed math in 3rd grade, and have since then have vowed to prove to the world that they can count.
Now, to finish the Virginia Pilot story...

On my way back to work from my dinner break, I passed by the newspaper stand again. I stopped the car and got out to take a closer look. I read the headline and the caption underneath it:

3,000
Less people have died from cancer this year

I blinked. I sighed with relief. I got back in my car and drove back to work a happier man.