Showing posts with label starvation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label starvation. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Meal Ticket


There were actually two versions of this cartoon. In the first version I didn't think the bodies looked enough like a leg, so I drew a seperate version and Photoshopped it onto the table. The first one was better drawn, but I think the second one is more effective.

Recently in my Contemporary Issues in American Politics class (geez that's a mouthful) the issue of America's stance against North Korea came up for discussion. The discussion was really centered around whether a hard-line was appropriate. From what one can tell, a hard-line approach includes either a military-only option or a case of "Don't talk to us unless you agree to our terms." The arguments I always hear are, "North Korea only wants to talk" (uh...can't they do that without using nuclear weapons? and didn't they ruin any chance of that with their actions in the 1990's?) and "America has nukes, why can't North Korea?" (who would you trust more with a gun? Ghandi or Billy the Kid?)

Personally I have always supported a multilateral approach. The reason? Well, let's face it - we aren't the only ones ticked off by North Korea. South Korea and Japan both have concerns over the DPRK, especially of the North decides to develop nuclear weapons. China, who has long been an ally and supporter of the Pyongyang regime, has recently been having problems with North Korean refugees as well as diplomatic headaches regarding the DPRK's adventures with the west. Getting all these parties involved not only solves anxiety in the region, but also brings leaders together to agree on a single stance. One of the things that hurt Kim Dae-Jung's "Sunshine Policy" was that he could not get an agreement with President Bush on the matter. The other advantage with multilateral talks is that if you can get a deal all parties can agree with, there's regional pressure on North Korea - not just from enemies, but from allies. If bilateral talks continued and North Korea decided they didn't like what America had to offer, it would only be a Pyongyang-Washington affair. With multilateral talks there can be - and in fact, there has been - pressure from China to get North Korea in line. An example of how multi-lateralism can work is in the Road Map for Peace: a plan was drawn up that both Israelis, Palestinians, and Arab neighbors supported. With Hamas' election, there was pressure not only from parties within Palestine but from neighboring Arab nations - including Turkey, Jordan, and Egypt - for the new government to respect the peace.

One theory I have is that part of the nuclear talks may be that North Korea may be doing it for international food aide. We do already send North Korea food aide, but the nation still barely meets the average serving size for individual citizens. One can also consider that both talks took place during turbulant times in the DPRK's history: in the early 1990's agricultural reform was a failure and resulted in the starvation that reportedly killed over two million people; around 2002 there were major economic reforms that resulted in major inflation and extreme poverty. (the price of rice shot up 55,000%, while average wages only shot up about 2,000%) In both cases, nuclear threats were hinted at to get foreign attention shortly after the catastrophe. In both cases, the main benefit of North Korea's talks were further food aide. I am not implying there may not be nuclear aims among the DPRK's leaders, but this strategy could be an identified way for the regime to continue to exist. Sure, you can lie to your starving people and convince them they're living in a utopia, but if your people die off and can't even get up to work...well, what are you really ruling?

It's been said we don't know very much about the North Korean infrastructure, but we do know their foreign relation practices. China has made it a practice of threatening to withdraw aid if North Korea did not meet with agreements. In our own talks with North Korea, we can consider this when thinking of how to easily appease Pyongyang or bring them to the negotiating table. As for multilateralism, I still uphold it is the best and, in the end, only method to deal with Pyongyang. Someone in my class advocating bilateralism kept adding that the UN or other parties could get involved then...which, even though he wouldn't admit it when I brought it up, was multilateralism. There really doesn't seem to be any where around it.

By the way, when I mentioned the utopia thing in class I almost said "dinotopia." A classmate got a kick out of that.