Monday, July 31, 2006

"Loose Bolts"

This cartoon is bitter and crude, I will admit. It was done in response to the film "Loose Change," which is the big documentary on the conspiracy that the attacks of September 11 were orchestrated by the government. Now granted, the notion that the US government would murder 3,000 of its own Americans willingly would normally set off the absurd-o-meter in your head, but there are sadly plenty of people out there who want to believe all this. Remember my blog entry here about how people want to believe what they want to believe?

I've been accused of not believing the film because I don't want to believe that the government can do this sort of thing, but that's hardly the case - I don't like the film because it disgraces the tragedy of 9-11 by feeding into the government-fearing minds of simple-minded individuals. People keep saying the Bush administration puts fear in the people, but I think they put fear into themselves by believing rubbish like this.

Are you wondering what kind of half-truths it tries to pass off as full truth? An example in the early portions of the film has a quote from an individual who said that the plane was a military aircraft, thereby trying to show doubt in what type of plane it was. This is actually a horrible misquote of what the person originally said, which was:

"The speed, the maneuverability, the way that he turned, we all thought in the radar room, all of us experienced air traffic controllers, that that was a military plane you don't fly a 757 in that manner. It's unsafe."

They said "military plane" to compare what it was doing, not what it looked liked or was identified as. Any one watching the movie without this knowledge would not know that. They would nod their heads and say, "Yup, lemme tell you something, that wasn't a 757." This is not covering the fact that some of the "official explanations" mentioned by the film were never officially made, nor the fact one of the people they interview from Rolls-Royce about whether or not it was the engine of the airplane said later that he couldn't really say whether or not it was the plane's engine since, “I don’t build the engines. I am a spokesman for the company. I speak for the company.” Again, any one watching the film at face value with no prior knowledge of this or the will to do research afterward would never know this.

The film goes through examples of different buildings that caught on fire and didn't collapse, but even here their "evidence" is faulty. For example, the film claims "on February 23rd, 1991, a 38 story skyscraper in Philadelphia burned for more than 19 hours and spread over 8 floors. It did not collapse." In actuality, firefighters fought the fire for 11 hours before they evacuated the building because they feared it would collapse. They later tore it down because it was declared unsound. "Loose Change" also uses the example of a plane crashing into the Empire State Building in 1945, smugly adding that the Empire State Building is still standing. The problem is it calls the plane a B-52 bomber, which did not fly until 1954. The plane that crashed into the Empire State Building was a B-25...which is also a propeller driven aircraft approximately 1/10th the size of a 757.

One lie that took even me by surprise was the claim that Mayor Guiliani shipped off the remains of the World Trade Center before any one, even FEMA, could look at it. Considering the remains were there a good while as people looked through the wreckage, I find that hard to believe. My college roommate and good friend's dad is an insurance adjuster, and even HE was there looking at the ruins. Besides, the fact is FEMA and other government organizations DID examine the ruins of 9-11, and put their report up publicly. (a better example can be found here)

Want another half-truth? The movie quotes a fellow by the name of Wally Miller, using a statement from him that there were no bodies. Yes, there weren't any whole bodies, but Miller himself reported that there were plenty of remains and DNA evidence. Miller also said in another interview that "The real story is about what those people did, deciding to rush the [terrorists] and sell everyone else on the idea...where it landed is not what matters. The most important thing is that they be properly remembered." I wonder why they didn't include that quote in "Loose Change?"

Here's one of the biggest half-truths to me. "Loose Change" reports that it was recorded Flight 93 landed in Cleveland Airport. The problem is that this was originally reported by AP News outside of Cleveland, but was removed a few minutes later when it was found to be wrong. I had a discussion with a co-worker about this; he made the point that on face value it is true - it was reported that Flight 93 landed in Cleveland. However, my issue is not whether or not the filmmaker reported it as landed, my issue was he didn't add the fact it was changed later, nor did he really go at it non-objectively. His slant on it was, "Flight 93 landed in Cleveland...hm...suspicious!"

Throughout the "documentary," the narrator continually makes the claim they found no evidence of planes at the sites...yet they found not only parts of planes at the Pentagon and in Pennsylvania, but they USED some of the remains (especially the black box for the Pennsylvania plane) at Moussaoui's trial! "Loose Change" appears to think a few pictures prove all, and I guess that's true since pictures speak louder than words. I wonder why those pictures weren't used in the "documentary?"

My issue with "Loose Change" is not so much that it looks into the idea that it was a conspiracy. My objection to the "documentary" is that it looks at it on the conspiracy slant, and - like a Michael Moore film - presents half-truths and straight lies alongside real truth to fool the viewer into thinking everything is truth. That's my problem, and quite frankly the entire film disgusts me. It opens and closes with dedications to those that died during 9-11, but it does nothing except insult the memory of the victims and turns it into a laughing stock. Conspiracy theories by default are laughed at and not taken seriously, and unfortunately when a serious subject is attached to a conspiracy theory it loses it's value.

Think for a moment on the Kennedy assassination - does anybody remember any more what it was like to hear that the president of the United States had been murdered? All one hears is whether or not the single-bullet theory holds true. While I agree that an investigation is called for if there is any suspicion of foul play, we should not act as if the suspicion is true unless it is proven...and we should never forget the humanity inside us in dealing with such events. Imagine if instead of remembering the Holocaust for what it was (humanity's worst act against ourselves) all we heard was, "How much did FDR know?" "Did the Pope really do enough?" "Did the Jews deserve it?" "Are those concentration camps in the photos or factories?" etc etc etc...I think you get my point.

September 11 is, for me, one of the most personal moments in my life. On September 11, 2001 I wasn't worried about whether or not the Bush administration was out to get me or whether or not Osama bin Laden was left or right handed. I was worried if I would ever see my father again. For two whole hours I watched the Pentagon burn on national TV, my stomach knotted up tight and my eyes swelled with tears. I think few people can realize what that feels like, and I hope few people ever will. However, I was lucky - my father was there for me when I got home from school, and for that I will be forever thankful. Many did not see their relatives ever again, and my heart goes out to them, and I know they went through terrible grief I could not even begin to imagine. September 11 was a terrible tragedy against the American people, it was a new Pearl Harbor that reminded us there were enemies out there that could touch us, and that we had to stop them before they could hurt us further.

And that is why this film disgusts me.

The film The Usual Suspects has a great line in which Kevin Spacey says, "The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist." That's the real danger here - Al Qaeda is real, and they do want to kill us. Pretending they are not there did not work in the 1990's, and as a result September 11 happened. We can no longer ignore them for what they do to us and our allies, the same way we eventually could not ignore Japan in World War II. Films like "Loose Change" would have you believe (and tries to make you believe) that Al Qaeda is not a danger, and instead you should fear the men in black suits with sunglasses and buzz-cut hair styles. I am not saying our enemy is Islam, nor am I saying criticizing the government is wrong - we should remember not all Muslims are terrorists and that as a democracy it is our right to criticize the government if they do something wrong - but there are extremes to every side. This is one of them, and this is an extreme we cannot succumb to.

12 comments:

Dhampir said...

I've been to where Flight 93 landed. It's not an airport.

Tony said...

Really? What is it like then?

Tony said...

Or wait, was that sarcasm referring to Pennsylvania?

Tony said...

They have blogs like that, you know ;)

Tony said...

Here's a question I put forth to you:

I learned in my 20th Century Art class that one of the reasons the World Trade Center crumbled like it did was because of it's structure, which was somewhat terribly designed and that the way they fell was typical of what would have happened in that situation. Did you ever hear anything about that?

Anonymous said...

I've heard nutzing

Tony said...

Well dur, I know that much.

I was implying the way they fell. Some people claim the way they fell shows that demolition was used. I was taught in 20th Century Art class when we were learning about architecture that it was a design flaw.

Tony said...

True that.

Stupid question, but there are people out there that believe otherwise. I suppose the best thing to do is smile and nod.

Tony said...

Someone argued with me the designers would've taken into account a missile might've hit the building. Somehow I don't think the designers had that in mine.

Tony said...

Very good points, all around.

TankHammer said...

I didn't even think about all the paper/carpeting/ceiling tiles and cubicle material. That stuff goes up just as quickly as jet fuel.

When I first saw that film I was very stunned and emotionally hit. I had to talk it over with people to sort out what parts of the movie had valid questions and which were completely baited. I am glad that a film like this exsists where a lot of points are taken into account for the sheer purpose of sparking this debate. I want to see the counter-argument to "loose change" where they use a point-by-point explaination of 9/11 on a "what exactly happened?" basis.

The conspiracy-theorists have their film makers, where are the logical films?

Tony said...

I think the problem with that is you would never imagine answering something as obvious as "Al Qaeda did it," hence why not to many documentaries have come out on the subject. It would be like doing a documentary proving the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor, or proving that John Wilkes Booth shot Abraham Lincoln, or even proving that the Holocaust happened. When four planes are hijacked and used for terrorist attacks, Osama bin Laden says "I did it," and all the events and facts centered around Al Qaeda before, during, and after September 11 coincide with Al Qaeda orchestrating September 11, it seems rather sad that there are people out there who seriously think it was any one BUT Al Qaeda who did it.

There are some who believe the administration KNEW and didn't do anything. That is more plausible, but I don't believe it to be true. I can believe that someone on the lower end of intelligence gathering got info and tried to pass it up, and somewhere along the line it either got fowled up, lost, or a foolish higher-up didn't pass it along. This happened in relation to Pearl Harbor and the Ardennes Offensive, so it is very possible that history would repeat itself.

Getting back to documentaries on the subject, there are some documentaries that discuss the history and events around September 11, even planning by Al Qaeda and such. They don't prove little things like "Hey that isn't explosives blowing up!" so they can't be a direct counterpoint to "Loose Change." However, there are a lot of websites and blogs that counterpoint what "Loose Change" claims. This one:

http://screwloosechange.blogspot.com/

Is where I got a lot of my data from. There are countless others like 911myth and etc.