A caricature of Ann Coulter, the infamous conservative columnist and writer of many books. Well, "many" meaning a handful. I used the front page of her newest book as reference and drew this on a hotel notepad during an overnight stay. I think they were trying to make her sexy, but she looks sick. She reminds me of those Hollywood actresses that in their 30's or 40's lose a lot of weight to make themselves look younger.I recently read said newest book, entitled "Godless," which caused a big media storm because in it she criticizes the four New Jersey widows who spoke out against the government. I was curious to see what all the hoopla was about, and I wanted something political to read for fun. What did I think of it? Well, I've copy and pasted my Amazon review of it here:
Reading this book made me realize Ann Coulter is the literature version of Michael Moore for the right. More on that later.And there you have it. I bet it must have been real easy for her to openly criticize Darwin...I mean, you know, him being dead and unable to defend himself and all...
I picked this book up because I knew it was going to be extreme and figured, even if I disagreed with it, it was going to be good reading. Halfway through I realized my mistake, because halfway through this book gets unbearable. Why, you ask? Because you realize about 90% of this book is nothing more than fact dropping and personal, self-serving attacks against figures in the media and politics. When she was writing daily articles in the newspaper it was in small doses and humorous even if extreme, but here it just gets exhausting. If you had a drinking game where you had a sip every time she insulted someone or made a sarcastic remark you would be drunk by page 10. I keep hearing about Ann Coultier's sense of humor, but I really see no humor in this book, just rants and insults that made me feel I was reading a teenager's post at some internet forum. The funniest thing was listening to an interview with her on Bill O'Reilly in which he asked her, "Why do you insult people? Is it really that necessary?" She kept yelling, "Those aren't insults!" to which he read many of her exact words aloud. She stuttered a moment, then basically said, "All right, but they're true!"
As you can discern from all this, Coulter comes across as a very amateur writer, sometimes saying the most bizarre things as if they end the argument once and for all. For example, when she discusses water conservation she says "liberals are worried we're going to run out of something that literally falls from the sky." (pg 8) Uh, Ann? It comes from the sky because already existing water evaporated INTO the sky. This is something they teach you in 5th grade. She rants and raves about abortions, calling them "Nazi techniques," even though the Nazis themselves were against abortions. (at least, for "pure" Germans) She actually drops abortion into the argument a couple of times at the beginning of the book, using it for everything along the lines of, "Liberals believe this...JUST LIKE THEY BELIEVE ABORTION!" Play a drinking game in which you have a sip every time she mentions abortion, and you...uh...would still be drunk by page 10.
A lot of media frenzy over this book was Coulter's insulting of the New Jersey 9-11 widows, and to be fair that really isn't the entire book. If anything, I got that she was set out to disprove evolution, which she dedicates a whole three chapters(!) to. Like much of this book, it is full of ridiculous assumptions based on a handful of facts. One of her claims that Darwin's theory isn't true is based on the fact he didn't go into detail about the human eye - you've got to be kidding me; the circulatory system is one of the most complex biological structures in the universe, and she's splitting hairs over the EYEBALL?! She criticizes an article that says Darwin "also realized that constraints of food and habitat sharply limited population growth; not every individual could survive and reproduce" and claims it's false because after the Irish potato famine the Irish were still Irish (pg 243) - dear God, I don't know where to begin with THIS one! The article was referring to the very true law of nature that if a food supply runs out and a species cannot find another, they will die off - if a lion can't find food, the lion population suffers and allows other species to grow and develop. The Irish potato famine was an internal issue dealing with crop failure and poor agricultural practices, not related to the natural order of evolution. Coulter chooses to ignore a lot of the real evidence for evolution, instead quoting other people's criticism and saying, "There's no proof!" over and over again. She sounds very much like the early religious critics of evolution, who told Charles Darwin they would not believe in evolution until he took a monkey from a zoo and turned it into a human.
Her understanding of the history and philosophy of the evolutionary made me wince. She claims the defenders of Darwinism were at first not Harvard professors or science experts, but religious leaders when in fact evolution won over the hearts of noted professors at esteemed colleges in Europe and America, (yes, including Harvard) and religious leaders were one of the LAST to be wooed over. Coulter also goes down the cliché road of saying because of Darwin's theories Nazi death camps and Soviet gulags were made possible. (p. 268) Contrary to popular belief, the idea of "social Darwinism" existed long before Darwin wrote on evolution, and Darwin himself hated such sociological ideas, arguing that a ruthless policy of elimination would betray "the noblest part of our nature." Coulter's claim that atheists and evolutionists are trying to do away with religion is equally absurd: Darwin was a moral man himself and believed people should retain their religious morals, and there's really nothing in the theory itself that disproves God. Many scholars have even said that there's still room for God, just as the scientists she name-drops on page 263 still believed there was room for God even after their discoveries. Incidentally Galileo and Newton, like Darwin, got in scuffles with the religious leaders of their time - I wonder if Coulter is the modern day version of the Catholic officials who ordered Galileo to say his theories were wrong. In fact, this is probably why she spends so much time trying to disprove evolution - it isn't because there's some atheist/liberal coalition out there trying to kill God, (after all I know plenty of Christians who believe in evolution as well) it's because she, like many extremely religious people, believe that evolution is a threat against her faith. It's a smack in the face of the dogma of the universe, it's another thing that says, "That part in the Bible was wrong." You have to disprove that there's anything past the point in which man is what man is today, just as Renaissance era religious leaders had to disprove Galileo's belief that there was anything beyond the sky except Heaven.
A lot of fans of Coulter argue, "She makes good points!" Yes, in-between insults and sarcasm she does make good points, but her technique does not excuse that. Like Michael Moore, she takes half-truths and straight lies and presents it alongside real truth as if they are all on the same bearing. Even if her message is one of world peace, this method can never be supported. Besides, the excuse fans of Michael Moore give for his faults is, "He makes good points!" I'm sure very few Ann Coulter fans would admit that - just as I'm sure few Michael Moore fans would admit Ann Coulter makes good points.
Miss Coulter's outlook on liberal "science" can best be summed up by quoting Charles Hodge, an old-school clergyman and critic of evolution like Coulter, who said that "the Bible has little charity for those who reject it. It pronounces them to be either derationalized, demoralized, or both."

4 comments:
From the first time I saw her interviewed on TV I knew something was wrong with that woman. To put it bluntly, she comes across as a total bitch and a religious/conservative zealot who's main technique of debate is to start talking over anyone who might have something to say that doesn't conform to her narrow beliefs.
Is it just me or does anyone else notice that her portraits are always of her in some black aerobics tanktop sticking her boobs out? It looks more like "I just lost 50lbs in 30 days" than a respectable piece of literature.
Ann Coulter, I challenge you to prove your own exsistance.
AC:*she begins to speak*
ME: THERE'S NO PROOF!
AC: No y-
ME: NO PROOF!
AC: Sto-
ME: HOW DOES IT FEEL TO KNOW YOU'RE GOING TO HELL!?
You got a point there Joe. I saw an interview with her and another guy, and she kept blabbing and would get mad if the guy tried to get a word in. I easily remembered that Saturday Night Live skit where Dana Carvey was Ross Perot on Larry King Live and he kept saying, "Can I finish?! Can I finish?! Can I finish?!"
And yeah, Al, you're right in that she's way to conservative to really convince any one, just as there are Democrats and liberals who don't like Michael Moore because of how left-wing he is. Even my liberal-minded environmental science teacher in college said he never watches Michael Moore because he already knows what it's going to be like.
looks like someone has a soft spot for Darwin
I defended Darwin no more than I would have defended Newton or Galileo if she went after those fellows.
Post a Comment