One of my readers wanted me to do something on women's issues, so here's something on women's issues! Well, maybe one woman's issue. This was something I did in response to the Andrea Yates trial. For those who don't know, Andrea Yates was a mother in Texas who drowned her five children to save them from "demons." The youngest was six months old, the oldest was seven years. She eventually pleaded insanity, the cause of her actions being done by postpartum psychosis. To the best of my knowledge she is currently locked away in a mental institution, hopefully for the rest of her life.First off, I should make it clear that yes, she did suffer from a mental illness and that is what drove her to kill her children. She didn't fake it. Second, she had a history of mental illness, which begs one to wonder why she didn't seek appropriate help - it also makes one wonder whether postpartum psychosis alone was responsible for the murder. As this article from 4woman.gov explains:
Women who have bipolar disorder or another psychiatric problem called schizoaffective disorder have a higher risk for developing postpartum psychosis. Symptoms may include delusions, hallucinations, sleep disturbances, and obsessive thoughts about the baby. A woman may have rapid mood swings, from depression to irritability to euphoria.Third, it is important to note that many states and foreign nations have laws regarding this condition. Some are clear that it has to happen sometime after the birth, be linked to postpartum psychosis, and only affect the infant. Some are so arbitrary that they may say you can only kill within the first year, so if you murder your child 363 days after birth it's postpartum psychosis, yet if you murder your child 367 days after the birth it's normal murder. The point I'm making here, however, is that this isn't a single case, it's actually a legal practice by many western nations.
However, one thing I cannot agree with is the notion that postpartum psychosis is any kind of "excuse" for this murder. Is it a reason? Yes. Is it an explanation? Yes. Is it an excuse? No. She murdered her children, and the fact she did it not in a proper state of mind makes it all the more senseless and makes Andrea Yates all the more dangerous. When a dog goes mad and kills a human, do we feel sympathy for the dog? No. Also, don't forget Jeffrey Dahmer had mental problems, sincerely believing he could drill into a person's head and turn them into a sex zombie. What sympathy do we feel for him? In fact, he didn't even get the insanity plea. If his victims had come from his loins, it might've worked better for him.
I also have to say I dislike the excuse, "Oh, you're a man, you don't know what it's like." To me this is like saying, "Oh, you're not poor, so you can't judge a person who shot up a 7-11 clerk to steal money." As I said before, I understand the insanity plea, I do think she did it while insane, and so long as she is locked up and unable to do harm I will be happy. However, the only sympathy I have is for her five children who were drowned by their own mother, one at a time. I cannot even begin to imagine what that would be like as a sane person.
The actress who played Magda Goebbels in the film "The Downfall" broke down crying several times while they were filming the sequence where all six of the Goebbels children were poisoned. It was because she had children of her own.

6 comments:
I think you should go back and revise the first paragraph where you say "The youngest was six months old, the oldest was seven months." Either this woman had a very busy month or there is a typo here.
I appreciate the argument that murder is murder whether you had control of your actions or not. I do not think an insanity plea should lighten a punishment, but I do have sympathy for someone who (through no direct fault of their own) winds up with a mental imbalance, leading to the deaths of their children. Imagine what this woman felt like when she realized the reality of her actions. If a friendly dog contracted rabies and attacked people, I'd still feel bad that it got rabies in the first place.
Oops, I'll fix that typo.
Maybe she was busy, and that's what drove her crazy.
You're such a sexist Keiper. You have no something something appreciation something something something slavery something something hitler something stalin something something 181st trimester abortion something.
I support a 435.74th trimester.
ROAD TRIP!
EVERYONE IN THE OFFICIAL LION'S DEN BUS! (copyright 2006 of Lion's Den Productions)
Post a Comment