Over the weekend I saw the movie "Syriana." Had to be one of the most overrated movies I've ever watched - cliche characters, predictable storyline, and a plodding script. It basically said, "America is evil, terrorists are good guys, and all our oil comes from the Middle East." In fact, the latter seems to be the battle cry of much the anti-war crowd. You hear slogans like "No blood for oil" over and over again. You constantly hear people talk about our reliance on Middle East oil, and any time you get involved with any nation in the Persian Gulf it's immediately labeled a play for oil interests. Of course, whenever I hear something repeated I'm curious how accurate it really is. Therefore, I decided to do my own study on whether or not we're really involved in Middle East oil as the anti-war crowd would have you believe.My main source was the website of the Energy Intelligence Agency. (EIA) They had a comprehensive list not only of American petroleum production, but also a history of how much we received and where we received oil from 1973 onward. Here is where I started to find my answers and began to crunch numbers.
For starters, let's make it clear what I’m looking at specifically. The numbers I'm using come from America’s total crude oil and products, from the 2005 annual report of a thousand barrels per day. I chose 2005 because it was the EIA’s most recent report, and one can only assume from the patterns seen that very little has changed in the past several months. I will explain my reasoning and factors succinctly so that no one assumes I'm purposely trying to play around with numbers or present only a half-truth.
Let’s look at the total number of crude oil imports from 2005, and compare it to how much of it comes from OPEC member nations and how much from non-OPEC member nations.
All Countries - 13,527
- Non-OPEC - 8,019
- OPEC - 5,508
One can discern from these figures that OPEC influences over 40% of America’s crude oil imports. While this isn’t a majority, it is still a scary number to learn. Remember OPEC does not necessarily equal Middle East - its members include non-Arab nations such as Venezuela and Nigeria. So that brings us to our fine point: how much oil DOES come from the Middle East? EIA actually provides a ready-made number at 2,298, labeled as “Persian Gulf." Is this number exact? I wanted to make sure.
Let us first look at the region most commonly known as the Middle East; this refers to the region centered along the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers, where any war started by western powers will be labeled as a “war for oil.” After compiling the oil received into the United States from Egypt to Iran, I came up with these numbers:
Saudi Arabia - 1,523
Iraq - 522
Kuwait - 231
Oman - 24
United Arab Emirates - 18
Egypt - 15
Yemen - 13
Syria - 10
Israel - 5
Qatar - 4
Bahrain - 0
Iran - 0
(Not listed: Jordan, Lebanon)
Total - 2,365
How much is this in reference to America’s total imports? It amounts to just 17% of America’s imports. This is fairly accurate to the assumptions of many that only around 15% of our oil comes from the region. On another note, I left out Turkey because I felt it is often a player in both European and Middle Eastern politics, and therefore it is often tricky to call it a Middle Eastern nation. However, if we were to include their numbers the percentage would barely rise to 18%, reaching just below that figure.
Now, because I know many people are a stickler for words, I began to include North Africa into the equation as well. This region, from Morocco to Egypt, is often grouped into the Middle East region because of cultural and religious similarities between the people and governments. Let’s see how these numbers match up:
Algeria - 477
Libya - 56
Morocco - 2
Tunisia - 0
Grand total (Turkey included) - 2,921
Combined together, the North Africa and Middle East regions make up just 21% of an influence on America’s oil imports. If Turkey is left out, the figure remains around 21%.
Now, let’s look at America’s top ten trading partners in crude oil:
Canada - 2,172
Mexico - 1,646
Saudi Arabia - 1,523
Venezuela - 1,506
Nigeria - 1,147
Iraq - 522
Algeria - 477
Angola - 465
Russia - 398
United Kingdom - 387
That’s right, Canada and Mexico individually surpass even Saudi Arabia and Venezuela. Combined, they influence 28% of America’s oil imports - even more than the North Africa and Middle East regions combined. I often heard conservatives make the joke that if America was really waging imperialistic wars, why didn’t we invade Canada or Mexico first. Now I see that this argument has some validity.
I’ve checked the numbers in total barrels in 2005 and other variants on the trade data, and I have had similar findings. The percentages remain fairly consistent across the board.

18 comments:
20% is still a lot though, considering that if they cut you off I don't know where else would you get the oil? It's not like all the other sources aren't already taken by China or other competitors.
It can be argued that the USA attacked Iraq to gain control over its oil, to prevent the 20% from falling.
I'd assume that the US would just export less?
To Sex:
20% (then again, that's counting North Africa) is a sizable amount, but it hardly shows a total reliance on the Middle East. I've heard claims that we get 60% of our oil from the Middle East - as this study shows, that is far from the truth. We get nearly as much oil from Canada as we do from the Middle East itself. If it were to be cut off America would probably do what they did in 1970's/1980's and just find sources elsewhere. I doubt, with allies and trading partners like Algeria, Egypt, or Saudi Arabia, that all the Arab nations would suddenly and unanimously cut off all oil. It's a story worth of a Tom Clancy novel.
Also, there would be no reason to invade Iraq to "prevent that 20% from falling." It's a silly idea. First off, Iraq is NOT that whole 20%, in fact they make up just 3% of America's oil imports, so a war would have accomplished nothing. Second, we were getting oil from Iraq before the war. (I would imagine this coincides with the "Oil for Food" UN plan, though I can't be certain) Look at these figures from the EIA:
1995 - 0
1996 - 1
1997 - 89
1998 - 336
1999 - 725
2000 - 620
2001 - 795
2002 - 459
2003 - 481
There was no danger of losing oil from Iraq - so why would we invade Iraq to get the oil we were already getting? It doesn't make any sense.
They obviously go to war because they want the amount to be greater.
Then why didn't they invade Algeria? Then we could've had "Battle of Algiers 2" with Steven Seagal as the American colonel out to extinguish terrorism in the Arab district! (opening Friday)
Sultan raises a good point. Hypothetically it is not our current reliance on Middle Eastern oil, but the amount of oil currently posessed by that reigion that we covet. Iraq may export 3% of our oil consumption, but how much oil do they have that is not controled by U.S. interests?
Not a bad point to ponder. Unfortunately getting any hard info on this matter would be very hard to do, as there may not be an accurate account of all Middle Eastern oil supplies, both tapped and untapped.
I would rather we keep an agressive study going into alternate fuel sources, such as hydrogen distribution and ethenol/bio-deisel. If nothing else, it'll free up the U.S. from any immediate risk of another 'Energy Crisis'.
Note that I think that writing "oil" as the cause for all western military action in the Middle East is ignorant. I think we've already spent more fighting in that area than we ever stood to gain financially. Oil may be, and probably is one factor, but nothing is that simple. Politically, the Mid East is a hotbed of fanatical leaders and former-Soviet weaponry.
Religious zealotry is prevalent enough to control major political parties that make the Christian Republicans of the U.S. look like agnostics.
We tread lightly in places like North Korea because we have a lot of peaceful allies sitting in point-blanc range of that country, plus Kim Jong Il still plays by the rules, relatively. Terrorist factions aren't as easy to keep an eye on.
I've heard the idea that we got involved in the Middle East to sway foreign interests. The problem is, who's interests? Iraq had ties to other nations, but as the EIA shows we were getting oil fine and dandy from Iraq already. If there was a threat, it couldn't have been a major one. The only threat I foresee could have been an earlier revealing of the "Oil For Food" scandal and oil from Iraq being sanctioned again.
Another problem is that the "we invaded Iraq to thwart foreign influence" hypothesis is flawed in that it overlooks interests around the world. Someone told me "We're involved in the Middle East to block China," but if we really wanted to fight Chinese interests, why aren't we further involved in Africa then? China has invested heavily in the continent for the past five years, and are involved with countries like Sudan and Zimbabwe, as well as other African countries that have much resources (including oil) to spare. You could even look to some former Soviet states that have untapped sources of oil and infrastructure problems - why aren't we involved heavily in any of those hot spots?
I would've invaded regardless.
Hey, who wouldn't have?
George Galloway?
Well, him and Mister Rogers.
Mister Rogers, you're trying to seduce me.
Mr. McFeely's here, and he's got a package.
Rogers would have been all over Iraq. He fought in 'Nam.
Big bird, on the other hand. There's a man who would skip off to Canada in an instant!
Yeah, meanwhile Elmo's on a stage at an anti-war concernt chanting "No war!" over and over again.
Elmo - "No war! No war! HOORRAY!"
Elmo doesn't understand the issues. I bet Oscar's a republican and that's why they don't associate with him.
I bet Bert and Ernie are log-cabin Republicans, if you know what I mean *wink wink*
Post a Comment