Tuesday, December 19, 2006

I just love democracy

A famous quote by Winston Churchill goes, "It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried." That's something I've always lived by. I have always been and still am a firm supporter in democracy, both as an idea and as an institution. There are many forms of it, from the direct democracy (the people decide everything - the way the Greeks did it) and then there's indirect democracy. (or a representative democracy, which is what most western governments are) Either way, however, a firm democracy presents a stable environment for a government to rule. It presents balances of power, and allows outside influences from both sides of the argument to assist in the final decision making. Yet even in imperfect democracies there are still those influential elements that will restrict and control the leaders.

Take for example the "democracy" of Iran. It's hardly a perfect democracy; it's structure is a mixture of popular democracy and theocracy, and the government is known to restrict the powers of opposition voices and incite riots against political enemies. Even then, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad still has limitations to his power. There are, for example, economic leaders in Iran who would not like an UN-enforced sanction were it ever enacted, and would also not share the President's sentiments about stopping the sell of oil to major trading partners in the west. There are also the Iranian voters themselves, who can elect him out of office or elect out of office his political allies. This happened only a day ago in the elections for the Assembly of Experts.

Most of my readers are probably wondering, "What the heck is the Assembly of Experts?" The BBC has a nice description of it on this page. The Assembly of Experts section states:

The responsibilities of the Assembly of Experts are to appoint the Supreme Leader, monitor his performance and remove him if he is deemed incapable of fulfilling his duties. The assembly usually holds two sessions a year...Members are elected for an eight year term.
They are essentially democratically elected clerics (86 in all) who are the balance of power with the Supreme Leader and other religious bodies of the Iranian government. They recently had an election, (with a 60% turnout, no less) and results are not looking good for Ahmadinejad. His supporters are in a minority and failed to win key seat positions, with opposition parties (some who have been banned from participating in elections before) taking those spots.

Many political analysts have welcomed this move. Moderate conservatives and Reformists seem to be working together to counter Ahmadinejad and his right-wing allies. Thus far, it seems to be working, and analysts believe this will definitely influence the president in his actions. Once again, it's the benefits of a democratic society, even if it's not the best democracy in the world. If this were a dictatorship like Saddam Hussein or Adolf Hitler, Ahmadinejad could have easily had all the opposition members rounded up and executed, and then this wouldn't have happened. Tough luck, Mahmoud.

One can only hope Iranian voters will go further with this come the next elections. Iranian presidents are elected every four years, and Ahmadinejad's time for re-election will be in 2009. Parliamentary elections will be in 2008, so everyone keep your eyes on Iran the next few years. (if you're that interested) Hopefully Reformists will not be limited by the government as they were in 2004 - a very real possibility. I am, however, as always an optimist, and will hold my breadth and wait to see what happens.

In the meantime, a big pat on the back to the Iranians for making a statement not with the bullet, but with the ballot. An even bigger pat on the back to the fellow who long ago came up with that goldurn idea called "democracy."

5 comments:

TankHammer said...

Very well said. I too like that Winston Churchill quote. As faulty as a democratic rule can be, it's still far better to be under a democracy or republic than any other form of government.

While it's frustrating to deal with a 2-party system, it would be much more than an annoyance if it were only a 1-party system.

Tony said...

Yeah. We keep hearing about how a third party's gonna take control this election, but each time is a let-down.

Dhampir said...

Iran, a theocracy by nature, doesn't have "moderate" politicians by our idea of the word.

America, by virtue of being the single super-power will always be the eternal enemy- just as when there were two superpowers, both were the eternal enemy. The "Great Satan" (America) and the "Lesser Satan" (Russia). Now all their attentions are against the "Great Satan".

Moderates in power only means that they don't launch their nukes first.

Tony said...

Moderate voices do, however, support a more pragmatic approach to the west, rather than the helter-skelter approach Ahmadinejad goes for. You are right that a moderate in Iran may not be a moderate to an American, but they would still be a good thing for Iran. They would try to do away with the conservatives' tyrannical-like rule and hopefully allow even MORE moderate voices to prosper.

Even women, despite the circumstances against them, are beginning to have a voice as Iran slowly but surely enters the modern world.

Anonymous said...

I agree, Iran isn't the best examplke of democracy. If the majority votes for a person for, lets say president of the USA, that guy should become the president, right? That's what democracy is all about