This was inspired to by a double-standard I noticed with Google and Yahoo. (but in particular Google) There were two incidents: the first took place in America, the second in China. While the America incident was a single case, the China situation is still continuing as far as I know.About a year back, the Department of Justice went to Google asking for information. According to the BBC article, they asked for:
- A list of terms entered into the search engine during an unspecified single week, potentially tens of millions of queries
- A million randomly selected web addresses from various Google databases.
Yet, as the previously linked BBC article points out, there are already internet laws in action to safeguard data while allowing justice officials investigating crimes to search for what they need. The problem with this case was there was no crime being investigated, and some feared the Justice Department might set a precedent of being able to access anything any time they wanted.
Granted, whatever you think of this individual case is irrelevant to my point. The same month as this incident, Google opened in China. What does Google.cn do? It "blocks politically sensitive material to comply with Chinese censorship rule." One Reuters reporter in Beijing described how she couldn't find anything about the New York Times, The Washington Times, BBC News or any websites about Tiananmen square. Even more amusing, looking for banned or rebellious groups will redirect you to "condemnatory articles." Along with Yahoo, Google handed over personal data to the Chinese government. There was an incident in 2003 in which "Chinese police who had been monitoring message boards, blogs and personal emails, asked for the sign up account details of two anonymous bloggers. These were handed over by Yahoo China to the Chinese Government."
Google's argument for their actions is that it would "be more damaging to pull out of China altogether and says that in contrast to other search engines, it will inform users when access is restricted on certain search terms." Yahoo claims they do not have a say in the affairs of their Chinese branch, but many journalists point out that employees from the various companies are personally customizing the list of banned words even without Chinese interference. Chinese journalists involved with the national media admit there are "30,000 people involved in maintaining censorship within the Chinese government, monitoring information and discussions on message boards." They say, however, that while "each case is very sad for the people involved, fifty seven people arrested in a country of 1.4 billion is not very much." I would think even one person arrested for speaking out or thinking contrary to the government would be a tragedy.
So even if you say, "Google was right to defy the Justice Department," you have to admit there is some hypocrisy here. This is especially so as Google and Yahoo pride themselves in being able to let people access any information any time they need to. I'd like to say, "It's those evil corporations again!" but uh...well, that's borderline to going on about "the Man."

10 comments:
Regarding access to information, Google does not return more than 1000 results per query. You can check it out, type in "tree" which will return several million results, then click on "next" until you reach the 1000th record.
Every other search engine has a similar limit as well.
So while Google is good for individual users that want to find something good, it is totally unusable for large companies, statistical companies for example, that want to study a million pages to find out something. The Justice Department, in theory, wouldn't have to ask Google for search results, they could just download a few million sites and then analyze those. Unfortunately they can't do this. So they ask Google for it, which turns out to be a violation of rights.
So although Google officially supports research and development, it actually prevents research companies from doing any research. This is why we must destroy Google! :x
Regarding access to information, Google does not return more than 1000 results per query. You can check it out, type in "tree" which will return several million results, then click on "next" until you reach the 1000th record. Every other search engine has a similar limit as well.
That's interesting to know. Doesn't Google store the information, though? Like who typed in what, etc? I think that was what the government was after, more than just typing in a word and seeing how many results came up.
The problem is that America won't block Google just because they don't like them. (If that's a problem.) China will.
Interesting you mentioned that because China, for a while, did block Google initially. They let them into the country when Google agreed to comply with censorship laws like Yahoo had. So yeah, I don't like conspiracies but it seems from what they said and what they did that it's all about the money.
This topic does not stir up any outrage in me. Google is a private company and they can do what they want, double standards included.
Addendum: Actually, Google is a public company...as in it's stock-holder owned. But it's private in the sense that it's not owned by the government.
Yeah.
Dhampir, I deleted your double-post just to tidy up, hope you don't mind.
I didn't expect people to go into a rage over this, I was just pointing out the double-standard of their actions. I personally knew some people who acted happy that they had rejected government inquiries, as if Google was the bastion of free speech on the internet. This has shown otherwise.
Excellent article, Tony. I think that the reason for this double standard is that freedom is a right in America, whereas in many other places, it is a privilege, and one which is witheld at that. Something like this is expected of China, but shocking here in America. However, there is no excuse - both stories should be treated equally.
UPDATE?
Is it possible to get an update?
Wilhelm has a point. Or not.
I Googled "hypocrisy" and got this place
Post a Comment